Possibilities of Exploring the (De)colonial Processes in the History of Latin American Education from a Transnational Perspective (Part 1)
Rafaela Silva Rabelo
Universidade Federal de Uberlândia, Brazil
Chair(s): Rafaela Silva Rabelo (Universidade Federal de Uberlândia, Funding: FAPEMIG, Brazil)
The transnational perspective has been gaining space in the history of education in the last years. This is evident in journals and conferences like the Paedagogica Historica and the International Standing Conference for the History of Education. In books bringing together authors from varied countries, such as "The transnational in the History of Education" (Roldán Vera; Fuchs, 2019), or from the same country but exploring multiple connections, such as "Rethinking Centre-Periphery Assumptions in the History of Education" (Vidal; Silva, 2024), or projects with international collaborations as the Brazilian-funded "Knowledge and practices in frontiers: toward a transnational History of Education (1810-...)" –to mention a few examples – researchers from different backgrounds have gathered around the effort to explore their wide range of research objects from a transnational perspective. The transnational history is not a methodology but a way of approaching the research object. Therefore, the procedures may vary depending on the proposed objective and types of sources. It is not restricted to national borders, although it doesn't ignore the existence of national states, which makes some developments in the research unpredictable to a certain extent. Since it is not restricted to geographical borders, it can make it possible to discover and explore new connections and even find new artifacts or actors. More recently, discussions based on a decolonial framework have also been incorporated in the field, adding to the postcolonial perspectives (Ossenbach, Pozo-Andrés, 2011; Caruso, Maul, 2020; Caruso, Toro-Blanco, 2023). Such approaches enhance the possibilities of exploring the history seen from below, subverting the idea of center and periphery and educational transfers. This is particularly relevant for the Latin American context, where the setting of new educational systems formed part of the nation-state building process in the 19th and 20th centuries. This symposium aims at multiple ways a transnational approach can contribute to exploring the Latin American history of education and shed light on new connections or deepen the understanding of otherwise "traditional" themes. Furthermore, it brings the possibility of identifying and problematizing different methodologies that have been used. Composed of two panels, it brings together authors and discussants from Argentina, Brazil, Chile, Mexico, the United States, and Uruguay, whose research has focused on different themes in the history of Latin American education. Although diverse, with a timeframe spanning from the second half of the 19th century to the early second half of the 20th century, it's possible to identify common elements through the panels. The ways imperialism impacted education in different countries, the role played by international conferences, educational trips, and appropriation processes in shaping the educational systems in Latin America are just some of these aspects.
Presentations of the Panel
Puerto Rico as (De)Colonial Crossroads of the Americas: Unsettling Imperial Binaries through Transnational Research on Bilingual Education
Lauren Lefty Northern Arizona University, USA
The U.S. has served as an imperial power in the Western Hemisphere since the 19th century. The Cold War era was no exception, but rather an apex of interventionist foreign policy toward sovereign nations across the Caribbean, Central, and South America. In return, Latin America has been a leading producer of decolonial thought and revolutionary praxis since the 1950s, with education serving as a significant site of resistance to and negotiation with U.S. hegemony. Yet what happens when we focus our attention on what Carlos Alamo-Pastrana calls "the seams of empire," the people and locations that defy neat categorization as empire or colony, metropole or periphery? Puerto Rico is such a place. As a former Spanish colony with a distinctly Latin American cultural identity, it has also remained under U.S. jurisdiction since 1898. Puerto Ricans are U.S. citizens, but also arguably colonial subjects without representation in Congress or the ability to vote for president. Starting in the early 1950s, the newly formed Puerto Rican Commonwealth became a particularly strategic "laboratory" for American-style development. Its postwar economic program, Operation Bootstrap, served as a model of capitalist takeoff for the non-aligned and decolonizing Third World, with education the "cornerstone of development." Owing to this role, Puerto Rico also became a self-proclaimed "crossroads of the Americas," where U.S. and Latin American thought met and clashed. Hundreds of officials from the region came to visit the "island of how-to-do-it" throughout the 1950s and '60s, while Puerto Ricans traveled abroad sharing the Bootstrap model with the world. At the same time, around a third of the island's residents migrated—primarily to New York City—during the height of the American Civil Rights Movement. Education also became central to those struggles, as Puerto Ricans brought experiences from the Caribbean and Latin America to bear on the fight for first-class citizenship in the metropole, in conversation with the domestic Black Freedom Struggle. This paper will argue that through Puerto Ricans' colonial-transnational trajectories throughout Latin America and the U.S., many became leading figures representing U.S. interests in the hemisphere, but also channeling strains of Latin American political and educational thought onto U.S. soil, influencing the political culture and policies of the metropole in profound and lasting ways. To make this argument, I will discuss two key figures that represent this phenomenon: Jaime Benitez, former chancellor of the University of Puerto Rico and a strong representative of the Puerto Rican liberal establishment's border-crossing Cold War Pan-Americanism, and Antonia Pantoja, an influential New York-based Puerto Rican education activist and community leader. Using organizational, institutional, and personal papers, newspaper clippings, and published works, I will discuss the ways that both figures crossed colonial and national borders in thought and practice to produce a distinct approach to bilingualism and multiculturalism that had lasting impacts on education policy across the Americas. Ultimately, this paper aims to uncover previously unrecognized contributions of Latin American decolonial thought to the U.S. education system only made visible through a transnational framework.
Bibliography
Archivo General de Puerto Rico, San Juan, Puerto Rico
Center for Puerto Rican Studies Library and Archives, New York, NY, USA Rockefeller Archival Center, Sleepy Hollow, NY, USA
Archivos Universitarios, Universidad de Puerto Rico-Río Piedras, Puerto Rico, USA
Secondary Sources
Alamo-Pastrana, C. (2016). Seams of Empire: Race and Radicalism in Puerto Rico and the United States. University of Florida Press.
Barreto, A. (2001). "Statehood, the English Language, and the Politics of Education in Puerto Rico," Polity 34(1), 89-105.
Dávila, A. (1997). Sponsored Identities: Cultural Politics in Puerto Rico. Temple University Press.
Del Moral, S. (2013). Negotiating Empire: The Cultural Politics of Schools in Puerto Rico, 1898-1952. University of Wisconsin Press.
Duany, G. (2002). The Puerto Rican Nation on the Move: Identities on the Island and in the United States. University of North Carolina Press.
Marsh Kennerly, C. (2009). Negociones Culturales: Los intelectuales y el proyecto pedagógico del estado muñocista. Ediciones Callejón.
Lindo-Fuentes, H. (2012). Modernizing Minds in El Salvador: Education Reform and the Cold War, 1960-1980. University of New Mexico Press.
Navarro, J. M. (2002). Creating Tropical Yankees: Social Science Textbooks and U.S. Ideological Control in Puerto Rico, 1898-1908. Routledge.
Ramsey, P. (2010). Bilingual Public Schooling in the United States: A History of America's 'Polyglot Boardinghouse'. Palgrave Macmillan.
San Miguel Jr., G. (2004). Contested Policy: The Rise and Fall of Bilingual Education in the United States, 1960-2001. University of North Texas Press.
Thomas, L. (2010). Puerto Rican Citizen: History and Political Identity in Twentieth Century New York City. University of Chicago Press.
Torres González, R. (2002). Idioma, bilingüismo y nacionalidad: La presencia del inglés en Puerto Rico. Editorial de la Universidad de Puerto Rico.
"Our Children are not Little Europeans": Discussions on Character, Personality, and Latin American Idiosyncrasy within Educational Reformism (Chile, c.1920-c.1940)
Pablo Toro Blanco Universidad Alberto Hurtado, Chile
In 1934, the Second Inter-American Conference on Education was held in Santiago, Chile, with the attendance of delegates from almost all Latin American countries, along with the United States. Evaluating the event, Revista de Educación, the Chilean educational official journal, stated that the Conference had demonstrated “a cultural vigour that is making America aware of its own personality. The scientific power of Europe is viewed with respect, as is fair, but no longer with the humble feeling of inferiority of other times (...) The Continent prepares its intellectual values so that it can investigate for itself what its educational system needs, taking advantage of European stimuli, but without slavishly sticking to them, as was done before.” In a scenario in which transnational organizations in the educational sector still did not have the degree of influence they acquired after the Second World War, this conference can serve as a point of reference for presenting some thoughts on one of the many topics that arose during its sessions: the formation of character and personality. Thus, this paper aims to explore the discussions and conceptualizations about both concepts and emphasize the arguments that, in the 1920s and 1930s, sought to identify and define a specifically Latin American childhood and youth idiosyncrasy. Therefore, based on the approaches of Chilean pedagogical authors, the aim is to identify both the arguments that highlight the specificity of local and Latin American childhood and to detect the circulation of similar approaches in neighbouring countries.
Bibliography
“La Segunda Conferencia Interamericana de Educación”. (1934) Revista de Educación, 54, 3-6.
Segunda Conferencia Interamericana de Educación. Tomo I. (1934). Memoria General, Acta y Documentos. Universidad de Chile. Santiago.
Building Permanent Goodwill with "the Other Americas": Latin American Education as a Space for the Good Neighbor Policy Networks
Rafaela Silva Rabelo Universidade Federal de Uberlândia, Funding: FAPEMIG, Brazil
In July 1941, the eighth International Conference of the New Education Fellowship (NEF) occurred in Michigan, USA. This was the first NEF international conference outside the European continent and the first to take place during a war period, as the NEF was founded in 1921, with the post-war scenario being one of the factors that motivated its creation and shaped its principles. However, the 1941 conference had very peculiar characteristics that differentiated it from previous ones. Among them, it is possible to point out the war scenario, which in turn had an impact on the low participation of European educators, an increase in the Latin American presence, and the support of US government bodies in holding the conference. These elements together signal an inflection point. With the suggestive theme of "Education in a world of nations" (Programme, 1941) and an opening text in the program booklet written by Nelson Rockefeller, then Coordinator of the Office of Inter-American Affairs (OIAA), the 1941 conference was a space of entanglements between political and educational actors. Although it is possible to trace connections between the NEF and the Rockefeller family even before the conference in Michigan (Rabelo, 2021), the involvement of the OIAA in Latin American education was not restricted to the 1941 conference. Actually, funding an event with the potential to deepen connections with "the other Americas" was just one of the investments made by the OIAA, which included a wide range of projects towards Latin America (Cramer, Prutsch, 2012; Sadlier, 2012). Nonetheless, the OIAA was not alone in the effort to get close to the neighbors. Pulling the thread of actors supporting the NEF conference, other groups, such as the Department of State and the Pan-American Union, come to light. Taking the NEF international conference in 1941 as a starting point and the OIAA as a hub - a node with many ties, as described by Barabási (2003) - this paper aims to explore the intertwining between political and educational actors linked to Latin America, which, despite not being restricted to the context of the Second World War, got new nuances. The transnational perspective enhances this analysis by making it possible to explore networks that unite different institutions, agencies, and educators. The idea of the nation-state in this context is essential but not restricted to geographical borders once the entanglements involving state and non-state actors are vital to this discussion (Roldán Vera, Fuchs, 2019). The primary sources are correspondence, reports, and publications, mostly available in the Nelson Rockefeller collection at the Rockefeller Archive Center and part of the New Education Fellowship's and Progressive Education Association's papers.
Bibliography
Barabási, A. L. (2003). Linked: how everything is connected to everything else and what it means for business, science, and everyday life. Plume.
Cramer, G., & Prutsch, U. (2012). Americas Unidas! Nelson A. Rockefeller's Office of Inter-American Affairs (1940-1946). Iberoamericana, Vervuert.
Programme. (1941). Education in a World of Nations, Eight International Conference, New Education Fellowship, Ann Arbor, Michigan.
Rabelo, R. S. (2021). The New Education Fellowship, the Progressive Education Association, and the US Department of State: South America as part of a complex entanglement, Paedagogica Historica, 57 (1-2), 183-199. https://doi.org/10.1080/00309230.2021.1872660
Roldán Vera, E., & Fuchs, E. (2019). Introduction: the transnational in the History of Education. In: E. Fuchs & E. Roldán Vera (Eds.). The transnational in the History of Education: concepts and perspectives. Palgrave Macmillan.
Sadlier, D. J. (2012). Americans All: Good Neighbor Cultural Diplomacy in World War II. University of Texas Press.
Tota, A. P. (2000). O imperialismo sedutor. Companhia das Letras.
|