Nation branding: A bibliometric analysis (2006–2024) using VOSviewer and RStudio Bibliometrix with a research agenda
Mounia RAFAI1, Hicham Echattabi2, Vincent Mabillard3
1university cadi ayyad, Maroc; 2University Hassan II- Morocco; 3Solvay Brussels School of Economics and Management
Facing contemporary globalization and the intensification of international competition, nations are undergoing significant transformations in economic and geopolitical terms. Nation branding, a concept introduced in the mid-1990s by Simon Anholt, has become a strategic lever allowing countries to enhance their attractiveness to investors, tourists, and international talent. It is based on the development of an appealing and unique national identity, aiming to influence the economic, cultural, and political aspects of a country.
This study aims to provide a general overview of the existing scientific literature on nation branding and to understand its contributions, methodologies, and research gaps in order to propose a potential research agenda that delves into underexplored aspects of nation branding. To the authors’ knowledge, this is the first study to quantify the evolution of research on nation branding using a bibliometric approach focused exclusively on the concept of nation branding. Unlike previous studies, which encompass several related terms such as country branding, place branding, and others, this research focuses solely on articles incorporating "nation branding" as a keyword, ensuring a more targeted perspective on the evolution of this research field. The data were organized and presented using the VOSviewer software and Bibliometrix via RStudio.
This study, based on an in-depth analysis of 360 articles published between 2006 and 2024 in the Scopus academic database, highlights a continuous increase in academic interest in this field. The main findings of this study indicate that the historical evolution of nation branding reflects a shift from a purely marketing-driven approach to a broader strategy integrating political, social, and geopolitical dimensions.
It is worth mentioning that the journals Place Branding and Public Diplomacy and the International Journal of Communication stand out for their significant scientific impact in disseminating knowledge in this field. Influential publications, such as those by Ying Fan, Melissa Aronczyk, and Nadia Kaneva, focus on an in-depth exploration of the complex interactions between national identity, international perception, and soft power.
Methodological challenges remain, particularly regarding the measurement of the impact of nation branding campaigns and the sustainability of the results achieved. Current literature calls for a deeper exploration of digital tools, the role of global crises, and the ethical implications of this strategy.
Using Place Brand Identity for Sustainable Place Development: A Community-driven Approach.
Davide MAFFEI1,2
1Eurac Research, Italy; 2University of Innsbruck, Austria
In the wake of societal crises such as the COVID-19 pandemic and the challenges posed by climate change, sustainability and resilience have emerged as priorities for local communities and municipalities. This study explores how the development of a place brand identity can serve as a strategic tool to enhance both sustainability and resilience at the local level.
After defining these concepts in the municipal context and introducing place branding theory, practical insights are presented and validated through a case study conducted in a municipality in South Tyrol, Italy. In this case, local institutions and the community co-developed a vision rooted in their shared place brand identity. The findings highlight the role of public-civil society coalitions in creating a collective vision that fosters community belonging and ensures holistic and authentic place development.
The development of a place brand identity has multiple positive effects. Place identity emerges from socio-cultural meanings that stakeholders have about a place and its constituents (Botschen et al., 2017). The consolidation of abstract ideals into future development visions accompanied by concrete enactment plans acts as a shared identity across different stakeholders, supporting community belonging feelings (Botschen et al., 2017).
In addition, the involvement of major stakeholder groups of a place, including its residents, ensures the development of a vision that can be regarded as both ambitious and authentic (Maffei, 2023). A networked and multi-actor setting ensures that those actors that have a stake in a place can make their voice heard and co-create the envisioned place brand identity that can be then pursued and realized through multiple initiatives at different levels (Botschen et al., 2017; Maffei, 2023). The combination of citizens’ beliefs, public actors’ goals, and the elements of the place can not only increase public value but also represent an element capable of improving the distinctiveness and competitiveness of a place (Maffei, 2023). These aspects lay the foundations for the achievement of sustainability and resilience.
Sustainability and resilience are two different concepts, yet they are strongly related, with resilience sometimes seen as an additional, enhanced level of sustainability (Alibašić, 2018). Their common pursuit can therefore deliver multiple synergies so that the same resources and processes can be deployed to achieve both.
This research shows how a place brand identity can align diverse stakeholder interests, enhance public value, and contribute to a municipality’s distinctiveness and competitiveness. The study also integrates the UN Sustainable Development Goals, demonstrating their relevance for municipalities. The 17 United Nations Sustainable Development Goals (UN SDGs) represent a common reference for action worldwide towards a better future. These goals come with more specific targets to support actors in becoming sustainable in their activities.
Sources:
Alibašić, H. (2018). Sustainability and resilience planning for local governments. Springer.
Botschen, G., Promberger, K., & Bernhart, J. (2017). Brand-driven identity development of places. Journal of Place Management and Development.
Maffei, D. (2023). Brand-driven identity development of places: application, evaluation and improvement suggestions of the BIDP-framework. Journal of Place Management and Development.
Research on the Development of Education for Public Policy Communicators Responsible for Public Marketing: Toward the Realization of Educational Methods through an Transdisciplinary Approach
Tatsuro NIIKAWA
Doshisha University, Japan
Purpose of this study
In order to succeed in public marketing, it is necessary to have communicators who specialize in public policy. However, there are not necessarily many such professionals in reality. This report examines methods for cultivating policy communicators who can undertake public marketing, based on a methodology for public policy education using a transdisciplinary approach.
Research Methods
The success or failure of modern government activities in achieving their goals is largely determined by whether or not interaction with citizens and stakeholders functions effectively. The activities that promote this interaction are referred to as public marketing (hereinafter referred to as PM), which enhances the effectiveness of government and its policies and their implementation. PM aims to strategically clarify policy issues, deepen citizens' and stakeholders' understanding of them, and increase their empathy and trust toward policies and their implementation. While PM is actually carried out by various actors, there are common professional skills, knowledge, and abilities that are expected in such activities. Professionals capable of undertaking PM must fundamentally possess communication skills and be proficient in applying them. Such professionals are referred to as public policy communicators.
Public policy communicators recognize social issues, understand policies and the policy-making process, and engage in policy communication with citizens and stakeholders. Public policy communicator education aims to develop skills related to policy-making and policy communication. Policy communicators are required to understand various public policies and acquire policy communication skills. In order to communicate policies in an easy-to-understand manner, it is necessary to not only acquire knowledge about policies, but also to practically master methods of creating materials and giving presentations, and to improve communication skills. Furthermore, policy communicator education for promoting PM must consist of both theory and practice. This education is provided by both the public and private sectors.
Learners study public policy theory and practice not only in the public sector but also in the private sector, where they learn from the people who are affected by policies. Learners who have gained transdisciplinary knowledge are able to think and act not only from the perspective of government officials but also from the perspective of citizens.
Findings and significance of this study
Policy communicators who have grown through transdisciplinary learning play a role in reorganizing the relationship between the government and the people so that policy objectives can be better achieved. Policy communicators serve as a conduit for guiding appropriate responses to policy issues through communication with the public. They enhance the feasibility of policies by facilitating relationships between citizens and stakeholders involved in policy implementation. The cultivation of such policy communicators is made possible through transdisciplinary public policy education.
|