Conference Program

Overview and details of the sessions of this conference. Please select a date or location to show only sessions at that day or location. Please select a single session for detailed view (with abstracts and downloads if available).

 
Filter by Session Topic 
 
 

Session Overview - All times EDT

Login to access full session information.


Date: Wednesday, 12/June/2024
10:00am - 12:00pmConference Welcome and Keynote
Location: DS-R520 - Plenary Day 1

Dr Hamza Hamouchene's keynote will anchor this year's CASID conference entitled “Development and Insecurity in an Era of Overlapping Crises” with a discussion on the concept of poly-crises, their origins and underlying causes, and strategies for tackling injustices in a divided world.

This event will be in person and online. Please click on the link to join the meeting:

Click here to read more.

12:00pm - 1:30pmLunch Day 1
1:30pm - 3:00pm1.3.1 Beyond Nature: Unraveling the Political and Gendered Realities of Disasters
Location: DS-1520
Session Chair: Christine Gibb
 

Chair(s): Christine Gibb (University of Ottawa)

This panel critically interrogates the conceptualization of "natural disasters" within the discourse of development studies. By unpacking the sociopolitical and cultural complexities inherent in these events, the papers in this panel aim to disrupt the prevailing narrative that situates disasters as natural. Through examination of disaster response, recovery, and relocation, our objective is to illuminate the interplay of socio-political, cultural, and gender dynamics shaping the experiences of communities affected by disasters. Drawing on empirical evidence from cases in Pakistan and the Philippines, the papers offer nuanced insights into the gendered and political dimensions of disaster management. This panel seeks to initiate a scholarly conversation, probing the ways in which disasters are constructed within multifaceted social, political, economic, and ecological contexts, and exploring their intersections with broader development efforts. It invites scholars to engage in a thoughtful reevaluation of established paradigms in the study of disasters and their implications for academic and practical endeavors in international development.

 

Presentations of the Symposium

 

Fragmented Disaster Response: How Politics Affects Post-Disaster Rehabilitation and Recovery in the Philippines

Marinelle Lopez Distor
University of Ottawa

The Philippine government is divided into multiple levels: national, provincial, municipal and barangay-level. This makes the system prone to politicking, with political support in the country depending largely on political ties, parties, and alliances rather than a unifying ideology. These characteristics thus produce the risk of a biased disaster response, where allies of the incumbent government could prioritize the allocation of resources towards provinces, municipalities, or barangays under the leadership of allied party members or family members, excluding those from the opposition.

 

(pre-recorded) How do Religion and Culture Shape Women’s Access to Disaster Aid in Evacuation Camps in Pakistan?

Jehan Zeb, Christine Gibb
University of Ottawa

Pakistan has experienced numerous disasters since independence; many of these disasters were precipitated by floods. Recently, the massive 2022 flood affected and displaced millions of people. Similar to other disasters, women faced particular impacts and challenges during the disaster relief and recovery phases. Using an intersectional approach, this paper explores the roles of religious and cultural gendered norms and practices in shaping Pashtun women's disaster experiences at evacuation camps following the 2022 floods. The paper draws upon fieldwork conducted in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa Province, in which qualitative data were collected using interviews and focus group discussions with flood-affected women with varied socio-economic and demographic characteristics. The results show that religiously and culturally defined concepts of purdah, sharam, and honor affected Pashtun women's access to relief goods, aid, services, and facilities, which further heightened their vulnerability and risks to their physical safety, security, and health status. In highlighting the centrality of religiously and culturally defined gendered norms and practices in shaping women’s experiences with evacuation camps, the paper critiques the neglect of gendered religious and cultural concerns in mainstream humanitarian disaster response and recovery efforts.

 

The Governance of Post-disaster Relocation Sites as “Camps”

Christine Gibb
University of Ottawa

This paper reframes post-disaster relocation sites as camps, challenging the prevailing narrative of these spaces as enduring solutions. Drawing on empirical studies in the Philippines and Japan, it scrutinizes diverse forms of camp governance by state, faith-based, humanitarian, and civil society actors. Through lenses of loss politics, spatial practices, and resistance, the study reveals the persistent socio-spatial restrictions shaping survivor subjectivities. By privileging "incompleteness" over "finishedness," it highlights the ongoing struggles and agency of disaster survivors in navigating rules governing resettlement, unacknowledged meaning-making in post-disaster spaces, and subtle forms of resistance. This reconceptualization contributes to a nuanced understanding of the socio-spatial dynamics, emphasizing the importance of recognizing and addressing the continuing challenges faced by survivors long after the initial displacement has been deemed resolved.

 
1:30pm - 3:00pm1.3.2: An intersectional view on contemporary development issues
Location: DS-1525
Session Chair: Vida Shehada
 

Three-decades of disability movement in Nigeria: x-raying how leadership of disability movement has fared in the struggle against rights abuse and societal inequality

Paul Eneojo Yaro Okpanachi

University of Ottawa

Ineffective leadership have characterized disability movements in Nigeria across three decades. Leaders of most Disabled People Organizations (DPOs) here after referred to as disability movements in the country often prefer charity to rights-based approach. They hardly unite to champion a common course for members’ collective benefits just as each group adopts different methods in efforts to address their peculiar needs. This trend has continuously thwarted efforts to reduce the socio-economic, political, and cultural inequalities preventing persons with disabilities (PWDs) from participating fully in the Nigerian society. PWDs are most disadvantaged in terms of access to resources, education, and job opportunities. Living in a country rife with high inequality profile, they are therefore on the margin of society grappling with myriad of challenges. Ineffective leadership thus expresses itself in leaders’ predilection for charity, lack of unity and framework explaining disposition to separate approaches in finding solutions to groups’ needs. As I argue in this paper, leaders of Nigerian disability movements lag in activating the institutionalized disability laws to pursue a just and more rewarding rights-based approach. Whereas the society takes advantage of the laws’ ineffectiveness to perpetuate disability rights abuse. Hence, this research relies on the institutional theory as the most suitable theoretical the role of institutions in shielding the weak and vulnerable members of the society like PWDs. This research relies on secondary sources of data Including: published articles, newspapers, and organizations’ websites. It will also benefit from my personal experience as a Nigerian with a disability as well as archival sources of data collection.



Partisanism, ethnic chauvinism and the state of democracy in Africa

Gallous Asong Atabongwoung

University of Pretoria, South Africa

Partisanism and ethnic chauvinism have seen the willingness to trade-off democratic principles for potentially conflicting considerations such as political ideology and policy preferences in Africa. It is confirmed that ethnic chauvinism has thwarted the progress of democracy in the continent. As ethnic groups are caught in a reciprocal struggle for power to secure the interests of their group which in certain parts of the continent has witnessed an unprecedented rise of authoritarian leaders who defy democracy. In response, scholars and organizations are pursuing innovations to strengthen democracy in Africa. This study explores the causes of democratic backsliding in Africa and identify solutions to build more resilient democracy in the continent. However, the imperatives of partisanism and ethnic chauvinism are far more demanding than the claims of democracy. In the context of the precedent, this study seeks to answer the following research questions; What is the origin of partisanism and ethnic chauvinism in Africa? How has partisan politics and ethnic chauvinism reshaped patterns of political behaviour in Africa? What are the solutions to build more resilient democracy in Africa? Answers to these questions would be obtained through extensive literature review of secondary data that comprise of journal articles, government publications, websites, books and other relevant sources.



Looking for a Dream: understanding rural youth life-course in Colombia

Maria Margarita Fontecha, Silvia Leonor Sarapura

University Of Guelph, Canada

The voice of rural youth in the Global South is still missing from the sustainable development agenda and related academic research. Rural youth are one of the most underrepresented groups. Despite the fact that most of the global south population is young and lives in rural areas. Academic literature has largely failed to capture rural youth voices and neglected youth’s experiences and positionality regarding the places where they live. The existing literature on rural youth is largely focused on economic aspects, which considers youth as labour in agricultural production. Few articles consider other aspects that might have a direct influence in rural youths’ decision-making process such as their role models, relationships with their surrounding community, and social norms, which ultimately impact their own agency and capacity to explore and pursue alternative life trajectories.

This research study provides relevant data on the prevailing conditions that influence decision-making processes in rural areas of Colombia from the perspective of rural youth. In the communities where the research was conducted, legal and illegal economies co-exist. This presentation is based in the results of participatory research to make participants collaborators in the study. To do that the research conducted four photovoice projects and focus groups. The research study evidences that although the macro structures (economic, social) and the regime (community) influence the decision-making process, rural youth's self-determination might explain why some individuals choose one life-course or another. Therefore, a systems-based approach is required to explore and understand rural youth realities in the Global South. Understanding what aspects influence rural youth decision-making processes provides critical information to design and implement age and context-appropriate policies and programs.



Extractivisme, conservation et conflits en Afrique de l’Ouest

Nicolas Hubert

Université du Québec à Montréal, Canada

Cette communication présente les résultats d’une recherche interrogeant la relation entre projets de développement, gestion des ressources naturelles et conflits en Afrique de l'Ouest. Elle interroge la manière dont les impacts socio-environnementaux et politiques suscités par le développement minier, l'agriculture intensive et l’encadrement des aires naturelles protégées contribuent à l'émergence de tensions et conflits localisés pouvant s'interconnecter aux conflits armés en cours dans la sous-région, mais également aux initiatives locales pouvant gérer et mitiger ces conflits. Issue d’une collaboration scientifique, cette recherche étudie une zone transfrontalière partagée entre le Togo, le Bénin et le Burkina Faso. Plusieurs terrains de collecte des données sont en cours de réalisation, au premier trimestre 2024, par des équipes béninoises, burkinabè et togolaises afin d’évaluer d’une part les impacts socio-environnementaux des programmes de conservation de l’environnement et d’évaluer d’autre part les impacts socio-environnementaux des activités extractives et agricoles intensives menées dans la périphérie immédiate de ces espaces de conservation de l’environnement. Les données sont constituées d’entrevues semi-dirigées réalisées auprès des femmes et des hommes issus des communautés riveraines des aires naturelles protégées et des projets de développement ciblés par l’étude, ainsi que des représentants des autorités traditionnelles, des représentants politiques et associatifs, des autorités administratives et des forces de sécurité des communautés et régions ciblées par l’étude. D’un point de vue théorique, cette recherche permettra autant d’interroger les injonctions contradictoires du développement, que d’enrichir la connaissance des approches en sciences politiques, en droit international, en sociologie, en études du développement et en géographie sur les impacts sociaux, politiques et sécuritaires pouvant être générés par l’exploitation non responsable des ressources naturelles au sein de pays en développement.

 
1:30pm - 3:00pm1.3.3 Enjeux et défis de l’action climatique féministe en Afrique de l’Ouest
Location: DS-1540
 

Chair(s): Fernande Abanda (Inter Pares, Canada), Geneviève Talbot (SUCO, Canada)

L’action climatique féministe, entendue comme un moyen d’action et un cadre indispensable pour faire face aux injustices sociales et environnementales qu’engendrent et/ou aggravent les changements climatiques à l’endroit des femmes et des filles apparait comme une réponse essentielle à la crise climatique et aux injustices qu’elle génère. Les expériences d’organisations canadiennes et ouest-africaines qui la mettent en œuvre dans les zones côtières et insulaires au Sénégal, au Togo, en Côte d’Ivoire et en Guinée-Bissau à travers le projet Action Climatique Féministe en Afrique de l’Ouest ( ACF-AO) renseignent sur les défis et la pertinence de cette approche pour renforcer l’adaptation aux changements climatiques, réduire les inégalités de genre et soutenir la résilience des systèmes alimentaires. Le panel propose d’explorer les enjeux et les défis de l’action climatique féministe du point de vue de ses acteurs locaux en Afrique de l’Ouest. Le Panel se déroulera autour de 4 axes : (1) La pertinence de l’action climatique féministe, (2) le rôle des mouvements écoféministes ouest-africains dans la lutte contre la crise climatique (3) les épistémologies et les savoirs endogènes sur les changements climatiques (4) les solutions concrètes proposées par les communautés aux premières loges de la crise climatique au Sénégal.

Le panel mettra à profit la démarche et les résultats du projet ACF-AO en cours, financé par Affaires mondiales Canada et mis en œuvre par Inter Pares et SUCO et des organisations locales et militantes du Togo, Guinée-Bissau, Sénégal, Côte d’Ivoire, ainsi que de chercheurs au Canada. Ce panel permettra aux équipes du projet de partager certains résultats préliminaires, et d’enrichir le projet grâce à des points de vue externes. Il vise aussi à enrichir les réflexions sur la pertinence de l’approche féministe dans la recherche et l’action pour s’attaquer aux racines de la crise climatique et des crises inter reliées.

 

Presentations of the Symposium

 

L’action climatique féministe : une réponse aux défis particuliers que pose la crise climatique. Leçons tirées du projet ACF-AO dans les zones pour les populations côtières et insulaires de l’Afrique de l’Ouest

Eric Chaurette
Inter Pares

Les populations des zones côtières et insulaires d'Afrique de l'Ouest sont parmi les plus vulnérables aux changements climatiques. Composant déjà avec des sécheresses, leur environnement est plus exposé à l’érosion, à l’intrusion d’eau salée et aux inondations. Des pratiques agraires non durables ont aussi appauvri les sols menaçant leur sécurité alimentaire et accentuant la pauvreté et la migration.

Les femmes et les jeunes femmes sont encore plus vulnérables en raison de normes patriarcales leur attribuant un statut socio-économique inférieur. Aussi, leurs rôles domestiques font qu’elles sont responsables de fournir l'eau, le bois de cuisson, les aliments et plantes médicinales à leur famille; des tâches de plus en plus ardues avec les changements climatiques.

Pourtant, les femmes ont un rôle essentiel dans l’action climatique et la protection de la biodiversité. Leurs savoirs locaux sur les ressources naturelles et leurs approches holistiques de pratiques agricoles ainsi que leurs aptitudes de collaboration font d’elles des leaders toutes désignées pour non seulement mettre en place des stratégies pour aider leurs communautés à mieux s’adapter au climat, mais aussi de participer pleinement au développement de politiques et initiatives durables.

Une approche féministe permet non seulement de reconnaitre le rôle de chef de file qu’occupent les femmes dans les luttes de justice climatique, mais permet aussi de s’interroger sur les causes profondes de cette crise et les autres crises inter-reliées. Cette intervention porte sur l’action climatique féministe, en tant qu’approche. Elle revient sur sa pertinence, mais de façon plus empirique, en se penchant sur les expériences du projet Action climatique féministe en Afrique de l’Ouest, l’intervention illustrera surtout à travers divers témoignages et exemples, comment cette approche tente d’amplifier des réponses locales d’adaptation au climat tout en interpelant/ dialoguant avec les décideurs pour des mesures et politiques qui s’attaquent et transforment les fondements des multiples crises.

 

L’évolution de l’action climatique féministe en Afrique de l’Ouest

Khadiatou Sarr1, Mariamé Ouattara2
1UQAM, Canada; CIÉRA, ( Centre Inter Universitaire des études et recherches Autochtones), 2Inter Pares

Cette intervention porte sur la lutte et les actions des femmes et des filles rurales de l’Afrique de l’Ouest pour bâtir un avenir radical qui allie justice, équité, droits, souveraineté alimentaire et résilience climatique, qui profite à tous. À partir des histoires de changements et du parcours des groupes de femmes du Sénégal, du Togo, de la Guinée-Bissau et de la Côte d’Ivoire qui mettent en œuvre l’action climatique féministe en Afrique de l’Ouest (projet ACF-AO), la contribution met en avant le rôle primordial qu’elles jouent dans l’action climatique par leur plaidoyer, leur engagement communautaire et les solutions innovantes qu’elles mettent en avant pour réduire les impacts disproportionnés qu’elles subissent du fait de la crise climatique et les conséquences. L’analyse ambitionne aussi d’enrichir les réflexions sur les dynamiques du mouvement écoféministe en Afrique, et en Afrique de l’Ouest en particulier.

 

Expériences et solutions concrètes proposées par les communautés des zones insulaires et de mangroves aux premières loges de la crise climatique. : le cas du Sénégal.

Selbé Faye1, El Hadji Faye2
1Enda Pronat, Sénégal, 2SUCO, Canada

Cette intervention présente les solutions communautaires d’adaptation aux changements climatiques mises en œuvre par les groupes de femmes, les filles et les jeunes de la Casamance et du Sine Saloum au Sénégal. Le Sénégal est l’un des pays particulièrement affectés par la crise climatique. Le pays connait une diminution des précipitations, des tempêtes plus intenses et une augmentation de la température d'environ 1,7°C (AMAA, 2022). Ces changements contribuent à la perte de terres arables, à la désertification et à une réduction drastique de la disponibilité de l'eau, ce qui affecte particulièrement les communautés des zones insulaires et de mangrove où ces effets s’amplifient considérablement. On y observe, une érosion de la côte, la disparition des poissons, la salinisation des terres et des eaux douces, la non-formation des huîtres en raison de l’usage des produits chimiques, et la disparition des autres crustacés et êtres vivants dans la mangrove qui est de plus en dégradée, ainsi que le manque d’eau potable dans certaines zones. L’expérience des populations de ces régions sénégalaises, et les solutions qu’elles mettent en avant pour s’adapter à la crise climatique renforcent considérablement les capacités d’adaptations et la résilience de l’écosystème; qu’il s’agisse de l’agroécologie, de l’utilisation de source d’énergie alternative telle que le solaire, de techniques ostréicoles résilientes aux changements climatiques, du renforcement des compétences locales et des actions de plaidoyer pour renforcer la participation des femmes dans les instances de prise de décisions autour des questions climatiques, En partant des actions posées par les communautés du Sine Saloum et de la Casamance au Sénégal, l’intervention décrira comment ces actions permettent d'amplifier les réponses communautaires à l'adaptation au climat en renforçant la participation des femmes et des jeunes à la gouvernance locale de la biodiversité et l’action climatique, en améliorant les pratiques agroécologiques et la réhabilitation d’écosystèmes

 

Valorisation et prise en compte des savoirs endogènes dans la gouvernance climatique nationale et internationale et la résilience des systèmes alimentaires

Luana Pereira1, Fernande Abanda2
1Tiniguena, Guinée Bissau, 2Inter Pares

Cette contribution vise à explorer les voies d’une valorisation et d’une prise en compte effective des savoirs endogènes dans la gouvernance climatique nationale et internationale, ainsi qu’une meilleure prise en compte des savoirs des communautés locales dans la résilience des systèmes alimentaires. Elle s’articule sur deux cas. D’abord le cas des savoirs endogènes des Bijagos de la Guinée-Bissau en matière de gestion des écosystèmes insulaires, notamment comment la pertinence de ces épistémologies et savoirs pour faire face à la crise climatique et la crise interreliée des systèmes agroalimentaires. La communication reviendra également sur l’insertion de ces savoirs endogènes dans la gouvernance des écosystèmes et le cadre national Bissau Guinéen de protection de l’environnement et d’adaptation aux changements climatiques. Ensuite, un pan de la réflexion abordera la place des savoirs endogènes sur le climat et les écosystèmes dans l’action climatique internationale tout en précisant les axes de plaidoyer d’une consécration effective de ces outils heuristiques et pratiques, essentiels pour juguler les crises contemporaines.

 
1:30pm - 3:00pm1.3.4: Digitalization in the International Development field
Location: DS-1545
Session Chair: Adrian Murray
 

Globalization and sustainable development: the mediating role of Digitalization in the EU context

Solomon Gyamfi, Mohammed Ibrahim Gariba, Faustina Owusu Ansah, Fazal Ur Rehman

University of Pardubice, Czech Republic

With an emphasis on the European Union (EU), this research explores the intricate link between globalization, digitization, and sustainable development. Extant research highlights how globalization contributes to waste reduction and pollution reduction, making it a major force behind sustainable development. The potential for sustainable development has been further enhanced by the extraordinary interconnectedness and information interchange brought about by the digital revolution. This research uses the Resource Dependency Theory (RDT) as a theoretical framework to examine the complex interactions between globalization, digitization, and sustainable development. RDT elucidates the dynamics of resource exchange across borders, providing a nuanced understanding of how globalization influences sustainable resource dependency. Notably, we investigate the mediating role of digitalization in the relationship between globalization and sustainable resource dependency, seeking to deepen our comprehension of their combined impact on economic, environmental, and social sustainability within the EU context. Utilizing partial least squares Structural Equation Modeling for analysis, our original findings reveal significant insights. We find that digitalization has a noteworthy influence on economic and social sustainability, albeit with a negative impact. Surprisingly, the influence of digitalization on environmental sustainability is positive, suggesting a more complex relationship in this domain. Furthermore, our research shows that globalization has a major beneficial impact on digitalization, highlighting the connections between these two processes. Specifically, we offer new proof that, in the EU context, globalization has a beneficial impact on social, environmental, and economic sustainability. By providing complex insights into the intricate linkages between globalization, digitization, and sustainable development, this research adds to the continuing conversation on this topic. The results highlight the need for a thorough comprehension of the complex processes influencing social, environmental, and economic sustainability in a time of unparalleled global connection and technology progress.



Harnessing Digital Technologies for Circular Economy: A Transnational Bridge to Sustainable Globalization in Africa

Mohammed Ibrahim Gariba, Dr. Mohammed Marzuk Abubakar, Mabel Opoku Gyau, Ibrahim Wannous, Hawawu Mustapha Yaajalal, Al-Mardhiyyah Adams

University of Pardubice, Czech Republic

The economic levels of African countries can clearly be distinguished from each other on the African economic development ladder. However, there are also ruptures and discontinuities at the regional levels. The very uneven levels of development that exist within Africa give rise to spatial discontinuities and thus initiate a positive dynamic of local cooperation and convergence or start a long-standing continental dynamic of territorial competition highlighted by localized patches of divergence. This article investigates the influence of sustainable globalization and digital transformation in bridging regional convergence in sub-Saharan African countries over a period of 6years (2015-2022). The research used social, economic globalization and digital skills as measures of globalization and digital transformation respectively. Despite the economic integration in the African countries, our finding proved that economic globalization has no significant effect on bridging regional inequalities. However, we proved a positive and statistically significant association between social globalization and the magnitude of regional convergence within Africa. Regarding the practical implications of our research, as we noticed in the theoretical discussions, some countries especially the eastern africa are lagging behind in terms of Globalization and digital transformation. It is an undeniable fact that, Globalization and digital transformation have had a significant impact on regional inequality, leading to increased economic disparities between regions. Therefore, policy makers should employ economic policies that will help bridge the regional inequality gaps amongst regions in Africa.



Digital rights in a fragile context: envisioning safer spaces for global solidarity.

Judyannet Muchiri

Memorial University of Newfoundland and Labrador, Canada

Emerging crises, rising nationalism, anti-rights movement, a collapsing ecosystem, among other priority issues, have resulted in a fragile global context. This context requires global solidarity that is informed by decolonial and feminist principles. Cultivating avenues for this solidarity is an urgent goal for activists, academics, and policy makers in the international cooperation sector. Digital technologies provide immense possibilities in this regard. Drawing on lessons from a research project with young women and advocates in Kenya, I showcase how we can leverage digital platforms as safer spaces for global solidarity. Digital platforms, although paradoxical spaces that are simultaneously safe and unsafe for particular groups, present an excellent opportunity to envisage pockets of safety that can nurture networks of care and community that are central to transnational solidarity. I also argue for the need to centre digital rights paying attention to the widening disparities in availability, accessibility, and affordability of digital technologies that are exacerbated by exciting global crises.



The Digital and the Uncertain Path to Development: A Global South Perspective

Mohamed Zayani

Georgetown University, United States of America

Over the past few decades, digital transformations have had a profound effect on the nature and structure of the global economy, impelling a move to a post-industrial economy that is based on technologically advanced, knowledge-intensive industries and anchored in the knowledge economy. Whereas in developed nations the knowledge economy is a central feature of growth, this transformation remains largely an aspiration throughout much of the Global South. This paper provides a critical exploration of the impetus the digital has brought to modernization efforts in less developed nations. Using the MENA region as a case study, it argues that the pursuit of the knowledge economy does not offer a linear path to modernization as many of the developing nations are faced with new challenges even as they strive to overcome long-standing impediments. The road to the knowledge economy is complicated by the structure of the region’s political economies, but also tied to other to a host of other factors that preclude the development of an enabling environment, including adequate (digital and physical) infrastructure, an overhauled educational system, policies and frameworks that produce more adaptive institutional bodies, and a strong culture of research and innovation, not to mention the digital gender gap and pressing environmental issues. The persistence of various socio-economic, political and demographic challenges is such that the same forces that propel development also impedes the region’s momentum for substantial or structural change.

 
3:00pm - 3:30pmBreak 2 Day 1
3:30pm - 5:00pm1.4.1 Gender, Security and Development
Location: DS-1520
 

Chair(s): Rebecca Tiessen (University of ottawa, Canada)

These panels (2 panels proposed as back to back events) explore various themes related to gender, security and development including the intersections between women, peace and security and human rights/LGBTQIA2S+; local indigenous perspectives on Peacebuilding, transitional justice, grassroots women's strategies for peace, and women's economic security.

 

Presentations of the Symposium

 

Intersecting Realities: Feminist Perspectives in the Conflict and Climate Change contexts in the Middle East

Lina Aburas Awadalla
uOttawa

This study critically examines the recent military escalations in the Middle East through a feminist lens. The research also explores intersections with broader issues such as climate change, aiming to provide a nuanced understanding of the complex dynamics in the context.

 

Bottom Up Transformation or Political Rhetoric? Lessons from Colombia’s Transitional Justice Model

Safo Musta
uOttawa

In this informal presentation I will introduce the main ideas behind my doctoral research project, centered on the post-peace deal developments in Colombia and its transitional justice (TJ) model. In 2016 the Colombian Government and the largest guerrilla group, the Revolutionary Armed Forces of Colombia-People’s Army (FARC) signed a peace deal ending 5 decades of internal conflict. In 2018, Duque, an opponent of the peace deal, was elected President and support for peace processes suffered, while the current left-wing government of President Petro won the 2022 elections on a pro-peace platform. Taking the impetus from these historic moments, I seek to investigate the extent to which promises for a transformative TJ have materialised since 2016. I question whether TJ processes in Colombia are a manifestation of bottom-up transformation or political rhetoric. I am also interested in comparing how implementation of peace processes is faring under the current (left-wing) government vis-à-vis the previous (right-wing) government. Finally, I seek to examine and discuss the role of the local (f)actors in the periphery vis-à-vis national (f)actors at the centre in influencing transformative change as I set to analyse the impact of the TJ processes from the eyes of women and marginalized Colombians in the periphery.

 

“What Homosexuals Need Is Help, Not Human Rights”: Ghana’s War Against Its Queer Citizens.

Ayewa Donkoh
uOttawa

Scholars have criticized Western empowerment metrics like Gender Empowerment Measure (GEM), the Gender and Development Index (GDI) and the Gender Inequality Index (GII) as elitist and Eurocentric. These metrics erase the invaluable work of African grassroots women’s organizations for women empowerment and present a truncated picture of (dis) empowerment.

In Ghana, major donor-funded and state-led women’s organizations dominate the women empowerment discourse while grassroots perspectives on women’s empowerment, which are more likely to represent the layered and intersectional realities of Ghanaian women, are pushed to the periphery. The purpose of my study is therefore to uncover Ghanaian grassroots organizations’ perspectives and theories on empowerment and how these influence their work on larger transnational discourses on the matter. This study will be an African feminist ethnographic study framed within the African (Black) Feminist Standpoint and Intersectionality theories that emphasize African women’s knowledge to decenter harmful hegemonic perspectives. Participants of the study will be two grassroots women’s organizations in Ghana, African Women Initiative (AFAWI) and Sirigu Women’s Organization for Pottery and Art (SWOPA). Data will be collected through participant observation, key informant interviews and document analysis.

 

Better than nothing?’ or ‘Nothing at all?’: The pursuit of women’s participation in peace processes through ‘advisory’ boards in Yemen & Syria

Madison Fillmore
uOttawa

.

 
3:30pm - 5:00pm1.4.2: (pre-recorded) Health perspectives on development issues
Location: DS-1525
Session Chair: Adrian Murray
 

Building Health Literacy and Numeracy through Oral Information Solutions among Poor Women in Northern Pakistan

Salima Meherali1, Saba Nisa1, Sobia Idrees1, Brett Mathews2, David Myhre2, Zohra Lassi3

1University of Alberta; 2My Oral Village; 3University of Adelaide

Background:

Health literacy and numeracy skills of women in Pakistan is very low as compared to other LMICs. Gilgit-Baltistan Chitral (GBC), a province in Pakistan, grapples with these issues, particularly affecting women who often lack access to skilled birth attendants during pregnancy and childbirth. To address these challenges, initiatives like the Aga Khan Rural Support Program (AKRSP) have introduced programs like Community-Based Savings Groups (CBSG), aiming to enhance women's financial means and facilitate access to maternal and child health services. However, despite these efforts, a lack of health literacy still hinders women's access to maternal and child health services.

Purpose:

The current study aimed to improve the health numeracy of unschooled women in Pakistan through the maternal and child health calendar (MCHC) mainly based on locally contextualized icons to support and improve maternal and child health care utilization and outcomes.

Methods:

A qualitative exploratory study was conducted to understand the usefulness of the MCHC. A total of nine in-depth interviews were conducted with key informants [staff of CBSGs] and five FGDs with unschooled women in CBSGs

Results:

The findings of our study are categorized into the following themes, (1) the benefits of using MCHC, (2) the usefulness of MCHC in their healthcare decision-making, (3) MCHC implementation challenges (4) empowerment of poorly-schooled women, and, (5) participants suggestions for improving the MCHC.

Conclusion:

We believe that MCHC will safely and sustainably build basic health numeracy and record-keeping capabilities for unschooled and illiterate women in Pakistan.



The Wider Impact of Covid-19 on Health and Well-being of Pregnant and Parent Youth and Their Children

Salima Meherali, Amber Hussain, Saba Nisa

University of Alberta, Canada

Background:

The COVID-19 pandemic has created an unprecedented impact on children, families, and communities around the globe. Pregnant and parenting youth (15-24 years) are a unique population, with particular mental and physical healthcare needs. The pandemic response measures to contain the spread of the virus have had significant and deleterious impacts on many areas of pregnant and parenting youth and their children’s lives. The wider and indirect impacts of the pandemic on pregnant and parenting youth and their children in Canada remain relatively unknown.

Purpose:

The purpose of this research was to investigate the wider and long-term impacts of the COVID-19 pandemic on pregnant and parenting youth and their children's health in Canada.

Methods:

Qualitative individual interviews were conducted with pregnant and parenting youth guided by social constructivist grounded theory.

Results:

Findings from the interviews are categorized into four key themes and subthemes: (1) Covid-19 impact on pregnant and parenting youth, Subthemes; Physical & mental health impact, impact on social well-being, financial impact, (2) Covid-19 impact on children, Subthemes; Educational impact, physical and mental health impact, social impact, (3) Impact on healthcare services delivery; Subthemes; Service utilization, access to healthcare, and (4) Suggestions from participants for improving parents' and children's health, Subthemes; Child care, financial needs, mental health support and other suggestions.

Conclusion:

This research serves as a critical foundation for shaping current and future policies, support services, and programs. The focus is on enhancing the support provided to pregnant and parenting youth, with a specific emphasis on addressing the challenges brought about by the COVID-19 pandemic.



Climate Change & Reproductive Maternal, Newborn, Child, & Adolescent Health (RMNCAH): Evidence Gap Map Exercise

Salima Meherali1, Saba Nisa1, Yared Aynalem1, Zohra Lassi2

1University of Alberta, Canada; 2University of Adelaide

Background: Climate change is rapidly evolving into a global health crisis, marked by devastating mortality and morbidity rates that disproportionately affect vulnerable regions and groups. This study focuses on women, adolescents, and children globally, aiming to strengthen the nexus between climate change, health, and the advocacy for the rights of women, adolescents, and children.

Objective: We aim to comprehensively understand the impacts of climate change on the reproductive maternal, neonatal, child, and adolescent health (RMNCAH), enabling the development of informed strategies and interventions to address the pressing challenges posed by this multifaceted crisis.

Methods: We conducted an Evidence Gap Map (EGM) following Campbell Standards. We used the EPPI Mapper software to generate an online evidence map, reporting findings in alignment with PRISMA guidelines.

Findings: We included 133 studies focusing on maternal health, 196 studies on under-five health, and 44 studies on adolescent health. Preliminary findings from these studies suggest that climate change events, including hurricanes, earthquakes, extreme heat, and extreme cold, have resulted in adverse maternal outcomes such as malnutrition, miscarriage, abortion, preterm birth, gestational hypertension, and prenatal/postnatal depression. Conversely, the impact of climate change events on adolescents includes post-traumatic anxiety, depression, early marriage, respiratory disease, domestic violence, and rape. As for neonates and children, the repercussions of climate change include vector-borne diseases, respiratory issues, anemia, preterm birth, low birth weight stillbirth, and neonatal mortality.

Conclusion: The findings of this study will facilitate the prioritization of future research and allocation of funding, while also suggesting interventions that may improve RMNCAH

 
3:30pm - 5:00pm1.4.3: Urban adaptation in Colombia
Location: DS-1540
 

Locals leading development in informal settlement upgrading: knowledge and perspectives of urban adaptation in Panorama, Colombia

Chair(s): Steffen Lajoie (Université de Montréal, Canada)

This roundtable conversation explores recent trends in locally-led development and climate change adaptation that focuses on local knowledges, perspectives and lived experiences and the contextual realities implicated in the processes of change. Climate change is yet another unwelcome challenge for informal urban neighborhoods. This impacts heavily on countries of the Global South like Colombia, and has informal settlements that characterize their cities at a boiling point. Risks linked to the natural environment pose a particular threat when they are mixed into a political and economic climate that has fostered inequalities and injustice. This is a challenge for development professionals, institutional actors and for civil society. For positive adaptation, these local actors, who are occasionally at odds, must find new ways of working.

Colombia, for example, is a neo-colonial context that has been fraught with discrimination, war, criminal violence, and political corruption. Despite these challenges, Colombia has been an outlier in terms of inclusive and pro-poor initiatives as seen through social and integral territorial planning. In informal neighborhoods like Panorama and Puerto Issac, civil society leaders and experts struggle for improvements by conserving greenspaces, promoting urban agriculture, and recycling clothing. To do so, they engage in more than livelihoods and innovations. They also involve themselves in community mobilisation, socio-political networking, partnership building, political negotiations, and compromise. While long term change demonstrates a heritage of success, the shorter-term socio-political challenges are daily.

This roundtable seeks to better understand the agency, power and influence built into locally-led development and the responsibility and weight that goes with it. Finally, the discussion will seek to co-produce new knowledge on how urban changemakers are working and how experts and other actors can better collaborate, support, and catalyse the foundational work done at local scales relevant to cities in Canada and around the globe.

 

Presentations of the Symposium

 

The indispensable contribution of regional civil society institutions

Laura Ramos
Fundacion Smurfit Kappa

Laura Ramos has worked in community development in Yumbo, Colombia for over 20 years. As a social worker, she provides capacity building for civil society organizations and their integration into municipal policy planning. provides an expert perspective on the challenges and successes of integrating neighborhood groups into mainstream urban development.

 

There are always setbacks and we always strive to improve our neighborhood

Miguel Ledezma, Diego Nieto
Fundacion FACY

Fundacion FACY has worked on environmental issues in Panorama for over 10 years. Don Miguel and Diego are active members of the foundation working hands-on planting trees and promoting urban agriculture. They will discuss the delicate balance between concrete environmental actions and the political dimensions of urban development.

 

Recycling clothing for women’s economic empowerment and the environment

Maria del Carmen Polanco
Associacion Resurgir

Maria is a leader and entrepreneur who has worked to improve her neighborhood for over ten years. Her recent initiative established clothing workshops throughout her neighborhood creating jobs and reducing carbon footprint and waste. Her contribution explores the opportunities in innovation and the political process to make it possible.

 
3:30pm - 5:00pm1.4.4 Multidisciplinary Network for Researchers and Practitioners of Education and Global Development
Prachi Srivastava1, Claudia Mitchell2, Blane Harvey2, Anushka Khanna1, Joseph Levitan2
1: Western University; 2: McGill University
Location: DS-1545
 

PURPOSE: This workshop will generate ideas for a potential network on education and global development. It builds on seed meetings to gauge broader interest, generate ideas, and plan future steps. The network is envisioned as a multi-/cross-disciplinary scholarly forum for Canadian researchers and practitioners working on issues related to education and global development, broadly aligned, to connect, share research, and collaborate. We invite faculty, early-career scholars, advanced graduate students, professional researchers, practitioners for brainstorming and a meet-and-greet with refreshments.

RATIONALE: Our times are characterised simultaneously by hyper-connectivity accelerated through intensified global flows (migration, technology, finance, media, ideas) (Appadurai, 1990), whilst in a context of de-globalisations (Yeates & Holden, 2022), anti-globalisation (Rizvi, 2022), and multiple inequities and social justice concerns. Education systems and learners at all levels face interlocking and potentially paradoxical challenges. Macro-level challenges for education in view of conflict, mass migration, climate emergency, and disease are already seen.

As idealised global calls for a new ‘social contract’ for education from a humanist perspective are proposed (UNESCO, 2021), threats to academic freedom, regressive macro-polities, mis-/disinformation networks, and advancements in artificial intelligence questioning the very nature of ‘knowledge’ are intensifying. Education at all levels must respond to a ‘VUCA world: volatile, uncertain, complex, and ambiguous’ (Stein, 2021).

This requires concerted interconnected, cross-disciplinary, open collective spaces for critical scholarly exchange. There is a need to question dominant knowledges and mobilise new and ‘othered’ knowledges, synthesise insights, and collaborate amongst researchers and practitioners engaged in the numerous issues affecting education and global development. While research and practice in education and global development are growing, disciplinary and sectoral fragmentation in Canada prompts scholars and practitioners to engage in academic associations and professional scholarly communities that usually do not have a dedicated space or structure for cross-exchange. The proposed network hopes to cultivate this community.

 
Date: Thursday, 13/June/2024
8:30am - 10:00am2.1.1 Development actors in their own right? Canadian CSOs and their relationship with the Canadian government
Location: DS-1520
 

Chair(s): Stephen Brown (University of Ottawa, Canada)

Canadian civil society organizations working in international development have consistently been a rich source of diverse ideas and practices that have shaped Canadians’ understandings of international issues and promoted social justice and equity in the global community. Many CSOs that have spent decades building strong relationships with partner organizations and communities in the global South report that the opportunities for federal funding have been shrinking and/or narrowing. The funding and regulatory environment for Canadian civil society organizations engaged in international development work has changed dramatically since 2010. Many observers of Canadian international development assistance have highlighted the devastating impact of the 2013 merger of the Canadian International Development Agency (CIDA) with the Department of Foreign Affairs and International Trade, creating what is now known as Global Affairs Canada (GAC), which has led to a loss of international development expertise and increasing red tape. Other trends in Canadian development assistance include the privileging of commercial interests over human rights, such as the Canadian government’s enthusiastic embrace of ‘innovative finance’ as a way to promote partnerships with the private sector and to meet the UN Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs). In addition, there has been an increase to humanitarian and multilateral aid, while proportionately less goes to bilateral programs. Furthermore, there have been important changes to the regulatory environment, such as rules on reporting on political advocacy.

This roundtable will focus on the impact of these trends on Canadian development and solidarity organizations, including how CSOs have positioned themselves by seeking non-governmental sources of funding for their humanitarian and solidarity work and advocacy.

 

Presentations of the Symposium

 

N/A

Denis Côté
AQOCI

Denis Côté (AQOCI) will discuss the funding and regulatory environment for the CSOs in Québec.

 

N/A

Heather Dicks1, Andrea Paras2
1Memorial, 2Guelph

Heather Dicks (Memorial) and Andrea Paras (Guelph) will present the finding of a recent SPUR Change report that addresses the what makes for an enabling environment for Canada’s international cooperation actors, focusing on small and medium-sized organizations.

 

N/A

David Black
Dalhousie

David Black (Dalhousie) will discuss the new politics of partnership, with emphasis on the changing inter- and transnational environment of ‘partnered’ norms and practices within which Canadian cso’s are required to operate.

 

N/A

John Cameron1, Heather Dicks2, Liam Swiss3
1Dalhousie, 2Memorial, 3Acadia

John Cameron (Dalhousie), Heather Dicks (Memorial) and Liam Swiss (Acadia) will present the findings of a study that looks at the relationship between federal funding and advocacy by Canadian charities, based on an analysis of 15 years of data from the Canadian Revenue Agency.

 

N/A

Karen Spring, Susan Spronk
Ottawa

Karen Spring (Ottawa) and Susan Spronk (Ottawa) will present the findings of a study that maps the experiences of Canadian civil society organizations with ‘innovative finance,’ particularly blended finance, based on interviews with key organizations engaged in international development and solidarity work.

 
8:30am - 10:00am2.1.2: Health and Wellbeing
Location: DS-1525
 

Exploring factors contributing to poor maternal health outcome in women presenting from conflict affected areas

Felagot Taddese Terefe

SPHMMC, Ethiopia

The aim of this study is to explore the existing barriers for access to basic obstetrics services that resulted in poor maternal health outcome in conflict affected areas.

Institution based qualitative cross-sectional study was undertaken in Ethiopia. The population for the study were comprised of all purposefully selected woman and families coming referred from conflict affected areas to tertiary hospitals. A total of 20 in-depth interviewees were conducted. The unstructured key informant interview (KII) guide was used to collect data to gain an in-depth understanding of the context in which continuum of care for maternal health care takes place.

The major reasons for poor maternal health outcome were categorized under three main themes: access to the health facilities; the direct effect of war, conflict and displacement on the women physical and mental health; healthcare system related reasons. Women who presented to the tertiary hospital don’t have safe road/transportation(ambulance) access to get to the proper health facilities. This resulted many women to reach to the facility with a critical and irreversible complications from preventable maternal health conditions. Many reached the facility many months after initial referral because of the political instability.

The war, displacement and conflict has resulted in increased gender-based violence in their community. This in turn was associated with increased unplanned pregnancy, complicated genital tract infections and HIV.

The war and conflict had also targeted many of the primary health care facilities in the community and resulted in destructions. This has led many women not to get access to the primary essential maternal health care services.

Healthcare for women in conflict-prone areas requires critical attention and should be given priority during the conflict. More large-scale studies are needed to fully understand and reduce the impact of conflict on maternal health care and look for possible solutions in tackling such challenges.



Exploring a reconceptualization of adaptive preferences as a tool for understanding survivors of sexual violence.

Laureen A Owaga

University of Guelph, Canada

The concept of adaptive preferences (AP) has been reimagined in diverse ways as a useful tool in the understanding of various forms of oppression, focusing on their root causes. This re-imagination has benefits that transcend the understanding of the concept itself, informing the development of interventions for mitigating the root causes of oppression. This paper tracks debates on AP with agency, autonomy, and rationality of adaptive preference agents. It argues for the use of Cudd’s reimagined understanding of adaptive preferences and makes the case that using this understanding is unique and important for understanding survivors of sexual violence. It argues that the reimagined frame of AP provides new opportunities for survivors of sexual violence to be understood positively as rational and autonomous individuals with agency. The reframing of the AP concept also helps to refocus attention on the root causes of sexual violence, exposing the complexities that these survivors have to navigate to cope. Lastly, the frame provides a more accurate backdrop from which sexual violence interventions can be developed. The paper concludes that, though controversial, the concept of AP provides a useful tool for understanding social problems like sexual violence.



(pre-recorded) Examining intersectoral collaboration among community health workers to address maternal and child health in resource-constrained settings in the Philippines: A qualitative study

Laura Jane Brubacher1, Lincoln Lau1,2,3, Warren Dodd1

1University of Waterloo, Canada; 2International Care Ministries, Philippines; 3University of Toronto, Canada

Achieving the maternal and child health-related Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) requires meaningful collaboration between different sectors. Community health workers (CHWs) are uniquely positioned within their communities to act as an intersectoral bridge and catalyst for collaborative efforts to improve maternal and child health. While CHWs are widely recognized as crucial actors in the health workforce, especially when state capacity is stretched thin, a need exists to critically examine the strategies they employ to facilitate intersectoral collaboration and improve maternal and child health, with an eye to informing the expansion of these programs across resource-constrained contexts. A case study was conducted in partnership with Philippines-based, non-governmental organization International Care Ministries and embedded within their ‘Community Health Champions’ (CHW) program. In April 2023, CHWs from six locations in Negros Oriental, Philippines were recruited for 11 participatory focus groups (n=75 CHWs) and 64 semi-structured interviews. Data collection focused on strategies used by CHWs to collaborate across sectors to improve maternal and child health. Qualitative data were thematically analyzed using a hybrid inductive-deductive approach. CHWs facilitated linkages between communities, non-governmental organizations, and the local public health system vis-à-vis working alongside public sector healthcare workers to identify individuals in need of support and to provide treatment or referral to formal care. This collaboration enabled a continuity of care, with CHWs viewing their role as addressing existing gaps within the public sector. Critically, CHWs' positionality and social networks held within communities shaped the degree and quality of intersectoral collaboration. Meeting the maternal and child health-related SDGs across resource-constrained settings demands intersectoral collaboration. This study highlights strategies used by CHWs as they embody and embed intersectoral collaboration in their efforts to enhance maternal and child health in the Philippines. Opportunities exist to further amplify these efforts and support CHWs to act as a bridge across sectors.

 
8:30am - 10:00am2.1.3: Environmental, Health, and Economic Perspectives on Climate Change Action
Location: DS-1540
Session Chair: Lina Aburas Awadalla
 

(pre-recorded) A search for ecological justice in the climate crisis

Kathy Bergs

University of Ottawa, Canada

With the fourth highest forest cover in Africa and highest amount of deforestation on the continent, at up to 300,000 hectares per year (earth.org, 2022), coupled with a populace of which 59% live below the poverty line and 48% are considered multidimensionally poor (UNDP & OPHI, 2022), Zambia was a logical choice for the introduction of REDD+ (Reducing Emissions from Deforestation and Forest Degradation). Theoretically, REDD+ has the potential to deliver multiple benefits as, in addition to mitigating climate change, it can support livelihoods, maintain vital ecosystem services and preserve globally significant biodiversity (CBD, 2012).

My empirical research into Africa’s largest REDD+ project by hectarage, the Luangwa Community Forests Project, seeks to determine whether benefits are being delivered and, if so, to whom. I further analyze whether this ‘flagship’ project is delivering ecological justice in its three dimensions of recognition, procedure and distribution (Visseren-Hamakers & Kok, 2022).

My methodology includes desk research, 33 key informant interviews, 6 focus group discussions and participant observation, allowing me to engage with approximately 282 stakeholders to date, both during an eight-week period in Zambia during June – July 2023, as well as virtually thereafter. My preliminary findings suggest that although problems of transparency and accountability plague the process, and benefit sharing mechanisms are highly contentious, there is merit in continuing to promote REDD+. Communities note cooler temperatures and higher rainfall in areas with standing trees, while carbon revenues provide a critical source of finance in areas with few other revenue streams.

REDD+ is not a silver bullet, but another tool in the toolbox. I argue that we need to improve an imperfect tool – not throw it out.



The politics of health and social equity in Nationally Determined Contribution Reports to the UN Framework Convention on Climate Change

Megan Arthur

The Australian National University, Australia

Current socio-political and economic systems are driving intersecting development crises due to climate change, social inequities, and health inequities. Existing economic and social inequities are compounded as climate change impacts are inequitably distributed between and within countries. This study examines the extent and nature of health and social equity considerations within national governments’ Nationally Determined Contribution reports (NDCs) to the UNFCCC, key objects of international cooperation for climate action.

Using quantitative content analysis and qualitative thematic analysis, we examine discussion within NDCs of social determinants that mediate impacts of climatic changes and socio-economic inequalities on human health. Inferential analyses also provide insight into country variation in report content, illuminating geopolitical tensions in countries’ responsibility for, and impacts of, climate change.

NDCs include greater discussion of economic issues compared to health outcome and social determinants-related content. Among high-income countries, we found moderate positive associations between levels of CO2 emissions and more frequent use of economic terms, and a negative association of economic language with levels of democracy. Democracy was also positively associated with discussion of equity and justice norms, indicating potential for impact through democratic pressures.

The relative frequency of economic frames in NDCs suggests that there is a need to reorient policymaking toward the inequitable impacts of climate change for development and health. We identify enabling and constraining factors for progressive climate change policymaking, providing critical insights for inter-governmental cooperation, mobilisation of national political will for regulating climate-warming emissions as a public health intervention, and advocacy to support these processes.



A messy mash-up of shadow governance and locally-led urban adaptation in informal settlements: perspectives from Panorama, Colombia

Steffen Lajoie

Université de Montréal, Canada

Locally-led climate change adaptation in informal settlements in the Global South is championed by community leaders and experts as an appropriate response to the climate crisis. However, adherents and critics recognise challenges in responding to diverse populations’ priorities; and connecting to action and policy at scale. In response, my research asked how the perspectives of local activists could help better understand the lived experience of adaptation in their informal urban contexts and how that could influence policymakers and practitioners to engage with it. I used a case study method with ethnographic approaches to answer these questions in a peri-urban neighbourhood in Colombia called Panorama. The results indicate that adaptation initiatives like greenspace conservation and self-built housing respond to a web of social, political, and environmental challenges connected to the post-colonial context, crime, and the climate. Residents, leaders, and experts in the case study navigate political networks and allegiances while advocating for their priorities, negotiating decisions, and compromising ideals. Adaptation responses are woven together in these complex visions for the neighbourhood through creativity and conflict. As a result, the data challenges mainstream adaptation approaches in local contexts that are technology and results driven and often referred to as top-down. The bottom-up side of the equation in Panorama demonstrated significant agency and power despite socio-political inequality and injustice that defined the context. The emerging cohort of climate adaptation and development professionals must take in these lessons to properly address the pressing crisis that climate change has integrated itself into.



Uncovering the impacts of women-centric lending programs on women’s empowerment in the Bolivian Aquaculture Sector

Sean Irwin1, Laura Parisi2

1Royal Roads University; 2University of Victoria

Women’s access to, and control over, finances at the household level is widely seen as a key element of building equality and women’s empowerment. In response, some governments and financial institutions in the global South have introduced a number of financial products and policies with the intent of addressing this issue. In Bolivia, rural lending for agricultural activities has begun to explicitly target women with low interest rate loans only accessible to women. This is viewed by the lenders and government as a successful tool in contributing to women’s financial empowerment, food security, and resilience, especially in the rapidly growing aquaculture sector where women have a high degree of participation in production and markets, and where access to credit for any borrower was limited only a few years ago. Yet little is known about Bolivian women's experiences with lending programs, and the metrics used to determine the success of this lending have tended to focus narrowly on repayment rates and number of loans given. Anecdotal stories collected through our work in the aquaculture sector over the past two years, however, have indicated that adverse effects of this lending program are present, complicating the empowerment narrative associated with the expansion of credit to women.

In February 2024 a survey will be conducted with 200 women heads of households of the 600 aquaculture farming families who make up the heartland of aquaculture in Bolivia. It will focus on how women access and control the loans they have acquired as well as the barriers they face in such acquisition. This presentation will share these findings, discuss their significance in terms of how to improve lending to women, and will outline how this can shape financial products that enhance women’s financial empowerment in the global South going forward.

 
8:30am - 10:00am2.1.4: Why Peace Professionalism Matters in Uncertain Conflict and Development Contexts
Location: DS-1545
Session Chair: Vida Shehada
 

Why Peace Professionalism Matters in Uncertain Conflict and Development Contexts

Philip Onguny1, Nathan Funk2, Evelyn Voigt3, Gordon Breedyk3, Peace Mukazi1, Victoria Gachuche1, Fatim Maiga2, William Jackson-Monrore1, Noman Sajjad2, Neil Arya5, Jessica Baumgardner-Zuzik4, Randall Puljek-Shank7, Allyson Bachta4, Jobb Arnold9, Jacinta Mwende6, Anna Snyder9, Lauren Levesque1, Richard Moore10, Luis Diaz11, Louis Santander8

1Saint Paul University, Canada; 2Conrad Grebel University College (University of Waterloo), Canada; 3Civilian Peace Service Canada; 4Alliance for Peacebuilding, USA; 5PEGASUS Institute, Canada; 6University of Nairobi, Kenya; 7Peace Academy Foundation, Bosnia-Herzegovina; 8BSocial, Colombia; 9Canadian Mennonite University, Canada; 10MDR Associates Conflict Resolution Inc.; 11Universidad Pedagógica y Tecnológica de Colombia (UPTC), Colombia

Peace scholars, practitioners, and policymakers increasingly recognize the pitfalls of focusing primarily on peace programming and related technical skills to achieve sustainable peace goals in constantly evolving conflict and post-conflict situations. Three broad reasons explain this recognition: First, studies show that insensitive attitudes, social biases, and ambivalence among peace professionals significantly increase fragility, conflict, and violence (Autesserre, 2014; Lederach, 2016) thereby jeopardizing development initiatives. Second, there is no straightforward path to becoming a peace professional, which contributes to less coordinated/integrated peace and development goals (Kastner, 2021; Scholten, 2020). Finally, the conduct and integrity of peace professionals is increasingly called into question (e.g., the reports of sexual misconduct by UN personnel in DRC). While these observations increase our awareness of the need and urgency to improve peace practice, there is no professionally shared approach to peace professionalism to increase the effectiveness and sustainability of peace efforts. This workshop focuses on the interrelationship between peace, conflict, and development in uncertain conflict and development contexts. Drawing on the sociology of professions (Evetts, 2006), theories of practice (Bourdieu, 1990), and participatory research methods, it addresses two interrelated questions: a) How do peace professionals know whether they possess the skills, competencies, and values necessary to be effective in their work? and b) What makes one an effective peace worker, particularly in uncertain conflict and development contexts? Overall, this workshop seeks to generate scholarly and policy debates around peace professionalism as a body of knowledge that informs both the process and approach to peace practice in uncertain conflict and development contexts. Workshop participants will reflect on some of the core values, competencies, and skills required to be an effective peace practitioner.

 
10:00am - 10:30amBreak 1 Day 2
10:30am - 12:00pm2.2.1: Overlapping crises in Sub-Saharan Africa
Location: DS-1520
Session Chair: Lina Aburas Awadalla
 

Building resilient food security in response to overlapping crises in Sub-Saharan Africa using a nexus approach

Cynthia Neudoerffer1, Stefan Epp-Koop1, Florence Nduku1, Maria Tendai Dendre2

1Canadian Foodgrains Bank, Canada; 2Zimbabwe Council of Churches, Zimbabwe

Canadian Foodgrains Bank supported a 33-month Humanitarian, Early Recovery, and Development (HERD) food security initiative in eight countries (Burundi, DRCongo, Kenya, Nigeria, Madagascar, Pakistan, South Sudan, and Zimbabwe). Participant communities were affected by high levels of acute food insecurity due to conflict, displacement, economic crises, and adverse climate events that were further exacerbated by the COVID-19 pandemic. Each project included humanitarian food assistance designed to increase immediate food consumption and early recovery and development activities to strengthen livelihoods and enable participants to improve resilience to current and future shocks. Gender sensitive approaches were woven into the responses and projects sought to strengthen gender equality, develop robust gender-based violence referral systems, and lay the groundwork for gender transformation.

The theory of change defined resilience as the amount of disturbance caused by shocks that a food system can absorb through coping, adapting, and transforming, while continuing to provide food security for all. A resilience analysis framework linked project activities to the development of coping, adapting, and transforming capacities which then contributed to increasing the ability of the food system to absorb the impacts from shocks, adapt to change through reorganization / self-organization, and transform through innovation, experimentation and learning.

The paper will present the results of baseline and endline quantitative household surveys ( ~ 2,800 respondents (64% female), 95% confidence interval and 5% margin of error) which measured the food security impacts of the program, complemented by a resilience analysis drawing from qualitative data collected through an outcome harvesting final evaluation using most significant change story harvesting to gather stories of resilience.

The success in contributing to resilient food security will be illustrated through a case study of one project implemented by Zimbabwe Council of Churches in Gutu, Bikita, and Chirumanzu districts, Masvingo, Zimbabwe.



Insecurity and care amidst climate change and conflict: a focus on the Lake Chad region

Gabrielle Daoust

University of Northern British Columbia, Canada

The relationships between climate change and insecurity, and the interacting effects of climate change and violent conflict, have been the focus of increasing political, public, and academic attention in recent years. Within academic literature, discussions have explored whether and how climate change contributes to violent conflict, as well as engaging in critical interrogations of these relationships, while research on environmental peacebuilding has drawn attention to aspects of cooperation in the face of environmental changes in conflict-affected contexts. However, there has been more limited in-depth attention to the different ways in which environmental and climate organisations and activists are framing, engaging with, and responding to climate change- and conflict-related insecurities in specific geographic contexts. Focusing on the Lake Chad region and drawing on a review and analysis of media and advocacy statements and sources, this paper will examine the work of environmental and climate organisations and activists who are drawing attention to the multiple insecurities associated with climate change and conflict in the region, and in turn the ways in which they articulate and enact forms of safety, community, solidarity, and care.



From farmer-herder conflict to banditry crisis: A study of north-central Nigeria

Plangshak Musa Suchi

University of Jos, Nigeria

North Central Nigeria is currently grappling with serious security crisis that have been traced to escalating conflicts between sedentary farmers and nomadic Fulani herders. In recent years, many communities in the region have come under recurring cycle of violent attacks by organised criminal groups thereby elevating the conflicts to the level of a security crisis. The crisis has led to loss of lives and livelihoods, and the destruction and displacement of communities with devastating consequences for food security. This paper analyses the overlap between farmer-herder conflicts and the current security crisis in North-Central Nigeria. Data was generated from in-depth interviews with farming and herding communities in three states of Benue, Plateau and Nasarawa within the region. Findings revealed that multiple socio-economic, political and environmental factors are at the roots of the farmer-herder conflict and the current security crisis. These include perceived or real political and economic marginalization of groups, explosive growth in human and cattle population, scarcity of grazing lands, and deep seated ethnic and/or religious animosity between farming communities and Fulani herders. Other triggers of the crisis include a combination of proliferation of weapons, availability of hard drugs, and utilization of children for cattle grazing in the context of weak and ineffective security and justice institutions. There appears to be a direct and mutually reinforcing nexus between the farmers-herders conflict and the banditry crisis in the region. To end the crisis, there is the urgent need for the federal government to address the underlying socio-economic, political and environmental causes.



Including young people in dialogues in times of crisis: An agentic way to look at Mali’s conflict differently.

Kattie Lussier1, Claudia Mitchell2

1PREAM project; 2McGill University

The decade-long conflict in Mali coincided with an escalation of inter- and intra-community tensions, rough climatic conditions, and political instability. All these factors caused living conditions to deteriorate and contributed to an increase in households’ vulnerability, especially for people living in conflict-affected areas. Although roughly 34% of Mali’s population is aged 10 to 24 (UNFPA, 2023), adolescents are rarely included in dialogues meant to address the crises. Yet, young people have ideas and could be instrumental in finding solutions to the country’s multiple problems. The project Participatory Research on Education and Agency in Mali (PREAM) used participatory visual methods such as drawings and cellphilms (Moletsane & Mitchell, 2018) as well as a survey of 1000 adolescent boys and girls to investigate the relationship between agency and education in conflict-affected areas. It showed that youth have concerns, experiences, and ideas that they wish to share about the crises.

The proposed paper will draw on PREAM’s findings, more specifically the insights from six youth-informed community workshops conducted in the third year of the project, to discuss how the participating girls and boys saw Mali’s multi-dimensional crisis and adults’ reactions to adolescent’s suggestions for peace and conflict resolution. The paper will argue that young people’s level of awareness of the circumstances in which they live can be higher than what adults might expect, and that young people have and want to share in proposing solutions. It will also assert that participatory visual methods are a relevant way to generate exchanges, bridge inter-generational barriers and enable adolescents, especially girls, to express themselves freely.

 
10:30am - 12:00pm2.2.2: Childcare, the Pandemic, and policy advocacy
Location: DS-1525
Session Chair: Fiona MacPhail
 

Childcare Amidst Crisis: Reshaping Neoliberal Discourses of Care in the Non-Profit Space

Meghan Mendelin

Queen's University, Canada

In the contemporary era of limited state support for public welfare, there exists a pressing global crisis of care. This crisis is marked by a widespread depletion of the capacities and resources for social reproduction, i.e., the processes and activities that sustain life itself (Dowling, 2021; Fraser, 2013; Mezzadri et al., 2022). In this context, non-profit organizations (NPOs) have emerged as important providers of essential goods and services (Baines et al., 2020; Strong, 2020), such as childcare.

Using childcare as a case study, this paper presents a comparative analysis of the discourse of care disseminated by International Non-Governmental Organizations (INGOs) and community-based non-profits. Drawing on a discourse analysis of NPO promotional materials and collaborative research with Canadian non-profit childcare organizations, the paper argues that INGOs pre-dominantly advance an individualized, apolitical, and financially-driven discourse of care, while community-based NPOs depict caring as a collective, highly political, and relationally diverse issue.

The paper stipulates that the way NPOs represent care has important ramifications for how the contemporary crisis of care is publicly understood and the types of policies which are demanded to combat it. The paper thus asks how we may shift attention from the discourse advanced by INGOs towards community-based NPOs’ narrative of care. How might this alternative discourse be disseminated to reach broader spheres of influence, facilitating the formulation and demand for sustainable strategies to combat the global crisis of care?

The paper illuminates the power of discourse in fuelling and combatting crisis, and underscores the pivotal role played by NPOs in the contemporary era of neoliberalism. The global crisis of care serves as a poignant indicator of the unsustainability of the neoliberal model, as the very capacities supporting is existence are increasingly depleted. Thus, in an endeavour to realize sustainable shared futures, reshaping the discourse of care is crucial.



Children’s Rights Education - A Grounding Orientation for Children within an Insecure Worldies

Heather Kathleen Manion1, Shelley Jones2

1Royal Roads University, Canada; 2Royal Roads University, Canada

Children’s rights education can offer a grounding orientation for children and youth within and amidst the prevalent insecurities that exist in this era of overlapping crises if, through authentic and integrative approaches (as espoused in the Vienna Declaration), it responds to the real challenges and experiences that children know in their specific contexts. However, there is a gap in the literature on effective processes for doing this. In response, this presentation shares the findings from a cross-country study on child rights education involving 20 elementary schools in four sites in Canada and Uganda. This participatory, multi-modal study draws upon both the United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child (UNCRC) and the African Charter for the Rights and Welfare of Children to explore how, by centering the voices of children through playful and participatory pedagogical approaches (e.g., drama, speaking, drawing, creating, singing, and playmaking) that reflect and respond children’s cultural, linguistic, socioeconomic and geographical realities can effectively augment official government curriculum whilst also building citizenship, respect, dignity, equality, inclusion, and agency. Outlining the power players within educational institutions, this approach challenges the status quo approach of adult-child power imbalances and offers opportunities for children to contribute to what and how they learn about their rights, roles, and responsibilities in the larger world. Findings from the study illuminate both the benefits and challenges, as well as the messy realities and efficacies that emerge when disrupting existing power structures within elementary schools in Uganda and Canada.



“Does government funding constrain policy advocacy by charities? Examination of CRA data on ‘political activities’, 2003-2018”

John Cameron1, Heather Dicks2, Liam Swiss3

1Dalhousie University, Canada; 2Memorial University; 3Acadia University

This paper examines relationships between federal funding and reported engagement by charities in CRA-defined “political activities” over the period 2003-2018. The analysis is based on data provided by the CRA from over 100,000 charities that submitted information returns. The 2003-2018 time period represents the lifespan of the CRA regulations on “political activities” (CPS-022), which were withdrawn and replaced by new regulations in 2019. While the ‘old’ regulations on ‘political activities’ are no longer in place, the data provide important insights into factors that shape public policy engagement by charities in Canada. The paper analyses policy engagement by all charities in Canada but focuses special attention on charities in the international development sector.

The paper examines correlations between receipt of federal funding and self-reported CRA-defined “political activities.” The analysis controls for variables including: size of charity, sector of charity, geographic location, federal funding as a proportion of total revenue, and proportion of reported spending on “political activities.”

Comparative research (mostly from the U.S.) suggests that government funding is positively associated with public policy engagement by charities, but that it constrains how charities engage in policy advocacy, leading them to adopt less confrontational, insider strategies.

The Canadian CRA data on “political activities” adds important insights because it specifically tracked ‘outsider’ advocacy strategies that involve public calls to action. While CRA data must be interpreted with caution, our initial findings suggest that federal funding is positively correlated with charity reports of “political activities.” The paper will include more detailed analysis that considers the control variables mentioned above (size of charity, etc.). The paper also engages with theoretical perspectives on policy engagement by charities, including ‘resource mobilization theory’ and the ‘paradigm of partnership’, and supplements quantitative analysis with data from interviews with charity sector leaders conducted between 2016 and 2023.

 
10:30am - 12:00pm2.2.3: Critical reflections on financing for security, solidarity spaces in fighting climate change, and volunteering
Location: DS-1540
 

Un profil de compétences pour les coopérants volontaires du Québec : Première perspective d’experts

Lauriane Maheu1, Philippe Longpré1, Sandrine Richard1, Sandrine Thibault1, Denis Côté2

1Université de Sherbrooke; 2Association québécoise des organismes de coopération internationale

Les organismes de coopération internationale sont des acteurs clés dans l’atteinte des objectifs de développement durable de l’Organisation des Nations unies. Leurs initiatives semblent avoir plusieurs retombées positives pour l’ensemble des parties prenantes. Toutefois, certains auteurs soulèvent des enjeux et des préjudices aux communautés locales, notamment l’entrave à l’avancement et à la complétion des mandats en raison du manque de compétences des individus prenant part à ces initiatives (Guttentag, 2009). Pour répondre à cet enjeu, l’élaboration de profils de compétences est une avenue prometteuse. Or, aucune étude n’inclut des personnes des communautés locales et plusieurs bonnes pratiques en élaboration de profil de compétences ne sont pas suivies (p. ex., Campion et al., 2011; Pettersen, 2000). Cette étude vise donc à créer un profil des compétences essentielles pour les coopérants volontaires du Québec en partenariat avec l’Association québécoise des organismes en coopération internationale. Suivant une version modifiée de la méthode Delphi (Rowe et Wright, 1999), 5 coopérants volontaires du Québec, 4 superviseurs employés par des membres de l’AQOCI et 3 employés d’organismes locaux supervisant des coopérants volontaires ont participé à des entrevues semi-structurées basées sur la technique des incidents critiques (Flanagan, 1954). À partir d’une analyse thématique (Braun et Clarke, 2006) des transcriptions, un profil préliminaire a été établi. Ce profil inclut 15 compétences avec une définition et des indicateurs comportementaux. Les compétences ont été regroupées en 4 grands domaines, soient le professionnalisme, l’ouverture culturelle, les relations interpersonnelles et les qualités personnelles. Il s’agit d’un premier pas vers l’élaboration d’un profil de compétences pour coopérants volontaires du Québec soutenu par des experts en coopération internationale et basé sur les meilleures pratiques en élaboration de profils de compétences. Ces résultats découlant de la première itération de la méthode Delphi, les suites du projet seront discutées lors de la présentation.



Le financement, nerf de la guerre des solutions africaines aux problèmes sécuritaires africains

Nicolas Klingelschmitt

Université du Québec à Montréal, Canada

Dans une volonté de privilégier des « solutions africaines aux problèmes africains » (Yohannes et Gebresenbet, 2021), les organisations internationales africaines (Tcheuwa, 2022) renforcent depuis le début du XXIe siècle la structure et les mécanismes d’action de l’architecture de paix et de sécurité africaine (APSA) (Döring et al., 2021). Cette volonté, bâtie sur l’idéologie panafricaniste (Boukari-Yabara, 2014 ; Tcheuwa, 2022), implique une souveraineté décisionnelle des acteurs Étatiques et institutionnels africains dans la gestion des enjeux de paix et de sécurité sur le continent (Muchie et al., 2017). Cette souveraineté décisionnelle doit néanmoins nécessairement s’accompagner d’une autonomie financière, problématique récurrente des organisations régionales dites du « sud global » constituant un nouveau pan de recherche à la croisée des études de développement et des organisations internationales (Mattheis et Engel, 2019). Le financement de l’architecture de paix et de sécurité africaine reste à ce titre une problématique à laquelle se consacre cette communication, l’autonomie financière de l’APSA vis-à-vis de partenaires internationaux étant pour l’instant loin d’être acquise (Stapel et Söderbaum, 2019). A l’inverse, nos recherches sur lesquelles se base cette communication montrent que les budgets des Communautés Économiques Régionales et des organes de l’Union Africaine (UA) composant l’APSA reposent en grande partie sur le soutien financier de partenaires extérieurs au continent, en particulier de l’Union Européenne (UE) et de ses États membres. Sur le plan méthodologique, notre recherche est issue d’une analyse de rapports d’organisations régionales et d’entretiens semi-dirigés avec des diplomates et fonctionnaires évoluant au sein de l’APSA réalisés en 2023. La communication mettra en exergue le paradoxe entre l’autonomie revendiquée par le narratif des composantes de l’APSA et leur dépendance à des financements exogènes. Elle montrera également l’étendue de la coopération entre l’UE et l’UA et relèvera les mécanismes visant à préserver une gestion afrocentrée de l’APSA.



Naviguer les paradoxes par l’organisation d’espaces de solidarité internationale pour lutter contre la crise climatique : le cas de l’AQOCI à la COP28

Katherine Robitaille1, Denis Côté2, Laura Wilmot3, Laura Fequino4, Noémie Lefrançois5, Mishka Caldwell-Pichette6, Carola Mejía11, Chennaiah Poguri7, Djibril Niang8, Fany Kuiru Castro9, Anne-Marie Milondo10

1Université Laval; 2Association québécoise des organismes de coopération internationale; 3Université Laval; 4Université de Sherbrooke; 5Professionnelle en environnement; 6Professionnelle en environnement; 7Peoples’s Coalition on Food Sovereignty; 8Jeunes volontaires pour l’environnement Sénégal; 9COICA; 10CBCS-Network; 11LATINDADD

Nombreux ont été les paradoxes soulignés à la 28e Conférence des Parties sur les changements climatiques (COP28) qui s'est tenue à Dubaï en 2023 (Lapointe, 2023). Malgré les appels des activistes à des changements radicaux, le choix controversé de tenir cet événement dans une pétromonarchie et la grande présence de lobbyistes pétroliers, agricoles et gens d'affaires ont créé des obstacles à la justice climatique. Les arènes décisionnelles climatiques, telles que la COP28, suscitent des appels au boycottage, mais ce luxe n'est pas universel. Plusieurs soulignent le rôle crucial de la société civile dans les pressions exercées sur les États (Brouillet, 2023). Cette complexité crée des espaces pour des luttes communes en solidarité internationale pour influencer les politiques climatiques mondiales. Dans ce contexte, cette présentation analyse l’organisation d’espaces de solidarité internationale, plus spécifiquement en reposant sur l'exemple de la présence de l'Association québécoise des organismes de coopération internationale (AQOCI) à la COP28, au prisme des théories des paradoxes (Clegg et coll., 2020) et de justice climatique (Mikulewicz et coll., 2023).

En s'appuyant sur une analyse documentaire, des observations participantes et des entretiens semi-dirigés, cette analyse présente comment l'AQOCI a navigué les paradoxes de la COP28 par l’organisation d’espaces de solidarité internationale pour exiger plus de justice climatique. En déployant une délégation jeunesse et en amplifiant les revendications de leurs partenaires des pays soi-disant des Suds, la présentation se concentre sur les manières dont la mise en place d'espaces de solidarité internationale peuvent être une stratégie pour naviguer les complexités des espaces décisionnels en matière de climat et contribuer à déconstruire les rapports de pouvoir (Sultana, 2022). Cette communication contribue donc empiriquement aux théories des paradoxes et de justice climatique en examinant la navigation des paradoxes dans un monde sous tension et les stratégies de lutte contre les injustices climatiques.

 
10:30am - 12:00pm2.2.4: Feminist Policy Impact and Activism
Location: DS-1545
Session Chair: Laura Parisi
 

The conflation of abortion, LGBTI+ rights, and sexual and reproductive health and rights in Zambia

Nomthandazo Malambo, Stephen Brown

University of Ottawa, Canada

This paper analyzes the parallels in the social, legal and policy challenges to LGBTI inclusion and abortion rights in Zambia, and implications for donor engagement. Drawing on qualitative field research on Canada’s engagement in sexual and reproductive health in Zambia – involving 44 semi-structured, in-depth interviews with Zambian and Canadian stakeholders – it answers the question, what explains the prevailing conflation of abortion, broader sexual and reproductive health and rights (SRHR) and LGBTI rights in Zambia, and what are its implications? The paper shows how LGBTI rights and abortion are stigmatized in similar ways, at the intersection of restrictive legal and policy frameworks, and religious prejudices. The state’s restriction of those rights reinforces its control over individuals’ sexual autonomy and delegitimizes SRHR more generally, with negative health consequences that go beyond LGBTI people and women needing abortion care, essentially limiting SRHR to family planning. This creates an unfortunate paradox: efforts to achieve greater social inclusion, often promoted by aid donors and other external actors, are actually leading to more state restrictions on SRHR and rights overall. As such, these initiatives require a more nuanced approach, one that is more sensitive to the complex contexts of SRHR and that prioritizes the perspectives of Zambian LGBTI and abortion rights advocates.



Women's Activism in Bangladesh: Affective Communities and Spaces of Social Reproduction

Nausheen Quayyum

York University, Canada

Workers’ institutions such as trade unions and workers’ centres are crucial for organizing workers. However, in much of the Global South, the ability of these institutions to reach out to women workers is limited. Taking as a case study the garment workers in Bangladesh, this paper explores the ways in workers and activists attempt to overcome the historic ban on trade unions in the country's largest export-earning industry by organizing beyond the production floor in spaces of social reproduction. In doing so, this paper bridges theories of social reproduction (Vogel, 1983; Bhattacharya, 2017) with a materialist reading of affect (Hennessy, 2013; Chun, 2016) to offer an analytical framework with which to better understand a critical aspect of labour organizing in Bangladesh that is often missed, particularly in the context of women’s activism: the development of affective communities. I argue that at once hidden and overlooked, these communities – and therefore, relationships – that women cultivate span from workplaces to spaces of social reproduction are crucial for developing the capacities for activism and strengthening workers’ institutions themselves.



In Search of Transformative Horizons: A Feminist Institutionalist Analysis of Canada and Transitional Justice in Colombia

Safo Musta

University of Ottawa, Canada

In 2016 the Colombian Government under then-President Santos and the largest guerrilla group, the Revolutionary Armed Forces of Colombia-People’s Army (FARC) signed a peace deal to end 5 decades of internal conflict. In the same year, Canada pledged $57.4M in development funding to help Colombia recover in the post-peace deal era. Since 2016 the Peace and Stabilisation Operations Program (PSOPs) alone has invested $35.3M in the country. With the launch of Canada’s Feminist International Assistance Policy (FIAP) in 2017, many of these initiatives unfolded in a new policy context and were characterised by commitments to make gender equality a priority. This paper looks at the intersection of Canadian aid, transitional justice, and gender in Colombia through a feminist-institutionalist lens. It aims to assess the impact of Canadian-funded projects from these areas in Colombia along a spectrum that varies from ‘gendered transitional justice’ to ‘transformative transitional justice’. The paper concludes that the impact of Canadian assistance is found in the in-between area of ‘gendered transitional justice’ and ‘transformative transitional justice’, characterized by some progress away from the status quo of ‘gendered transitional justice’, but without hitting the transformative mark. Through a feminist institutionalist lens, I argue that it is the complex socio-political landscape of Colombia overlaying the agency of Canada’s implementing partners, their Southern counterparts and the agency of the donor, and the sum of these interactions that both enable and limit the full transformative capacity of the intervention and situate its impact somewhere in the middle. The study applies mixed methods, including 28 semi-structure interviews with key informants in Ottawa and Bogota.



Transformative organizational and programmatic change? Civil society responses to the Canadian Feminist International Assistance Policy (FIAP)

Sheila Rao1, Ann Delorme2

1Concordia University; 2Humanity and Inclusion

The paper aims to examine how The Feminist International Assistance Policy (FIAP) shaped efforts of civil society organizations to address gender equality through organizational and programmatic change. FIAP and other feminist policies have direct implications in how organizations design and administer their work to address gender inequality, and on how funding agencies and foundations administer and support this work. What are the opportunities and limitations to the Feminist International Assistance Policy’s implementation based on experiences of civil society organizations’ efforts to address gender inequality? Data collection for this article took place between 2019 and 2021, beginning two years after the launch of the FIAP. This research adopted a mixed-method, grounded theory approach, where the data collected shaped the conceptual framework. An online survey, interviews, participatory

workshops, and media analysis were included in the data collection. Staff from civil society organizations and the University of Ottawa supported the research design process. Analysis from data collected in 2019 with gender specialists and staff of CSOs, as well as analysis of media coverage of challenges faced by feminist organizations in 2020 and 2021 revealed that the potential for CSO investment through staff support, (financial, training and government guidance) could

only be partially realized within the structural landscape in which development agencies oversee the administration of underrepresented groups.This study demonstrates the limitations but also the opportunities for building stronger linkages between policy formation and implementation processes. The authors argue that strengthening engagement with feminist networks globally could align policy priorities with those identified by grassroots movements, while influencing how funding agencies value feminist practice in civil society organizations.

 
12:00pm - 1:30pmLunch Day 2
1:30pm - 3:00pm2.3.1: Economic perspectives, financial assistance, and financial injustices
Location: DS-1520
Session Chair: Sean Irwin
 

Economic Challenges in Mid- and Low-Income Countries: A Comprehensive Analysis of Economic Insecurity, Sovereign Debt Crisis, Unemployment, and Inflation

Samuel Anobaah Awuku

Nexia Debrah & Co., Ghana

This abstract examines the interrelated problems that middle-class and low-income nations face, with a particular emphasis on sovereign debt crises, unemployment, inflation, and economic insecurity. The study explores these problems' underlying causes and effects, highlighting how they interact with one another and how they affect the economy. The main issue is economic instability, which is defined as erratic income, insufficient social safety nets, and increased financial vulnerability. Economic instability is exacerbated by the growing sovereign debt crisis, which also limits government resources and makes budgetary difficulties worse.

The many facets of unemployment's significance for both economic productivity and societal well-being are examined, making it a serious concern. Additionally, the study investigates inflationary pressures, analyzing the causes of price increases and the effects they have on businesses and consumers. The study emphasizes how critical it is to tackle these issues holistically, considering the complex interrelationships across economic variables.

The abstract also addresses international cooperation mechanisms and possible policy actions that may be implemented to lessen the effects of inflation, unemployment, sovereign debt crises, and economic insecurity. The results highlight the necessity of customized approaches that take into consideration the conditions of middle- and low-income nations while acknowledging the intricate interactions between local and international variables. In the end, the study advances knowledge of the complex economic issues these countries are facing and offers suggestions for viable paths toward long-term economic growth and recovery.

References

“Economic and Political Weekly 2004 Index.” Economic and Political Weekly 40, no. 31 (2005): 3497–3551. http://www.jstor.org/stable/4416969.

GILLS, BARRY K. “Going South: Capitalist Crisis, Systemic Crisis, Civilisational Crisis.” Third World Quarterly 31, no. 2 (2010): 169–84. http://www.jstor.org/stable/25677765.

Bakoup, Ferdinand. “GLOBALIZATION: A VARIABLE GEOMETRY PROCESS.” In Africa and Economic Policy: Developing a Framework for Policymakers, 135–60. Anthem Press, 2014. https://doi.org/10.2307/j.ctt1gxp7v1.13.



Industrial Pollution and Health Issues among Rural Citizens: Does Injustice in Financial Assistance Matter?

Fazal Ur Rehman

University of Pardubice, Czech Republic

The industrial pollution has created serious health issues among communities, raised fingers toward industries, and evolved regulators to take active actions but rare attention has been paid in rural areas. Hence, this study aims to examine the impacts of industrial pollution on the health of poor citizen in rural areas of Khyber Pakhtunkhwa (KPK), Pakistan. It also inspects the mediating role of injustice in financial assistance between the industrial pollution and health issues. Data were collected in quantitative way through questionnaire-based survey from the rural citizen in the surroundings of industrial zones and the sites of oil and gas extraction companies in rural areas of KPK, Pakistan. The collected data were analyzed through Partial Least Square Structural Equation Modeling (PLS-SEM) to find results. The study found that the industrial pollution has created serious health issues like respiratory diseases, cancers, decreased lung function, and asthma among the rural citizens of KPK, Pakistan. The study also found that the injustice in financial assistance mediates the relationship between the industrial pollution and health issues among rural citizen of KPK, Pakistan. The results have interesting implications for policy, environmental regulators, and elucidate the practitioners understanding to define more stable environmental policies, make sure the fair distribution of financial aids among the rural areas to control the health issues and infectious diseases, and build more sustainable societies. Even, prior studies have paid wide attention to the industrial pollution, health issues, financial assistance, but this is the first study in these domains.



Home Grown Solutions for Sustaining Shared Futures: Narratives from Rwanda

Jos Chathukulam

Centre for Rural Management (CRM), Kottayam, Kerala, India

Home - Grown Solutions play an important role in ensuring sustainable development. The Republic of Rwanda stands as a shining example in this realm. United Nations Development Programme (UNDP) has mentioned that “Rwanda’s recovery from the 1994 Genocide and its rapid economic growth, about 8 per cent on average over last 15 years, continues to be an inspiration to developing countries around the world,” (UNDP, 2021).

Rwanda’s transformation journey from obscurity to development was pioneered by “locally engineered policy innovations” known as home-grown solutions. Peacebuilding processes and initiatives in Rwanda was a fruitful result of home-grown solutions in the world. No other country in the world has effectively made use of the power of home-grown solutions than Rwanda not only in post-conflict resolutions and reconstructions but also in strengthening political, social, and economic transformations. In the last 20 years, the Rwandan government have come up with several home-grown solutions and notable among them are Gacaca (Community Courts), Girnika (One Cow Per Family), Umuganada (Community Work),

The introductory part of the paper offers a brief profile of Rwanda and traces the evolution of the home-grown solutions. The first part provides a detailed discussion on the ten home-grown solutions based in Rwanda including Gacaca (Community Courts), Ubudehe (Collectively Solve Problems), Girnika programme (One Cow Per Family), Umuganada (Community Work), Imihigo (Performance Contracts), Vision 2020 Umurenge, Community-Based Health Insurance , Tubarerere Mu Muryango (Let us Raise Children in Families), Itorero (Civic Education), Ingando (Solidarity Camp) . The third part of the paper critically evaluates the contribution of the selected ten home-grown solutions in enhancing participatory and accountable governance, reducing vulnerability, fostering social cohesion and nurturing inclusive human development. It is followed by a detailed discussion and conclusion on the need to adopt home-grown solutions to build and sustain shared futures.



Youth Leadership for Development Programs and the Coloniality of Development Discourse: An Auto(Bio)graphic Assessment

Ajibola Adigun

University of Alberta, Canada

The McCall MacBain and Schwarzman Scholarships, established at McGill University and Tsinghua University in Canada and China respectively join the growing landscape of Youth Leadership for Development Programs (YLDPs). These programs promise to cultivate a diverse cohort of scholars demonstrating leadership potential and a commitment to positive societal impact who can respond to the geopolitical landscape of the 21st century as global leaders. This paper explores the transformative potential of (YLDPs) through an autobiographical lens of three influential figures and canonical texts—Margaret Ajibola, Augustus Tai Solarin, and Shaun Johnson. Drawing on personal experiences in three YLDPs, the author, in conversation with other participants of YLDPs, addresses the fundamental questions about the purpose and impact of such initiatives. The popular mission school to incipient elite literature is critiqued and preliminary findings suggest that African participants of YLDPs are aware of the often conflicting but sometimes converging priorities of self, country and funders but make strategic decisions informed by the ecology of their choices. By combining personal narratives with critical inquiry, I take a methodological turn of grounding bodies of knowledge as canonical texts that contribute valuable insights into the transformative potential (or the lack therof) of YLDPs and the discourse on development.

 
1:30pm - 3:00pm2.3.2: (Neo)Extractivism and mining
Location: DS-1525
Session Chair: Fiona MacPhail
 

Varieties of (Neo)Extractivism in the ‘Lithium Triangle’: a Multiscalar IPE Analysis

Alicja Paulina Krubnik

McMaster University, Canada

Lithium continues to grow in importance and urgency as an asset in the international political economy (IPE) regarded for its potential in 'green' energy transitions necessity for technological advances, and over half of global resources are estimated to exist in Argentina, Bolivia, and Chile - the 'Lithium Triangle'. Nationally, the element is of great importance to these countries and has important implications on the development paradigms pursued by their states, which are argued to reflect varieties of (neo)extractivism. That Argentina and Chile are among the top three for proven reserves and Bolivia is not, despite it's relatively vast amount of resources and international demand, is testament to the importance of national governance and the role of state. (Neo)extractivism and the role awarded for lithium is also, however, necessarily impacted by the opportunities for and pressures on these states by powerful actors in the IPE.

To understand and explain the varieties of (neo)extractivisms across the Lithium Triangle, and thus the related opportunities and consequences, this paper develops the argument that it is necessary to consider inter- to sub-national dynamics that operate simultaneously and often across said scales. In doing so, it builds on the work of Svampa (2021) to advance an understanding of multiscalar political economy. Internationally, this research is also informed by critical and historical perspective of IPE as well as contemporary dependency theories to situate these three states relative to other actors in the wider IPE, with a particular focus on states. Trade agreements, exports, and extractive agreements pertaining to Lithium are examined to empirically support the arguments. Nationally and sub-nationally, power relations and institutional arrangements are examined to understand the ways in which domestic dynamics transform the role of lithium in (neo)extractivism, and how they resist or are primed for international influence.



Transformations in IFI-State Relationships and the Consequences to (Neo)Extractivisms in Brazil and Ecuador

Alicja Paulina Krubnik

McMaster University, Canada

International financial institutions (IFIs) have been critical to the outcomes of (neo)extractive state development paradigms in Latin America and the primacy of energy as a strategic focus for industrialization. Brazil and Ecuador, while distinct cases, exhibit patterns of commonality in this regard; they feature institutionalized developmental models since the "productivist" or "progressivist" turns that highlight hydrocarbon exploitation as a prominent means toward achieving development goals with varying forms of involvement from IFIs to do so. In particular, China has filled the gaps in for the Brazilian and Ecuadorian states where US-led IFIs are now more marginally and indirectly involved. Since the post-commodity boom era, the landscape of IFIs and their interests in Brazil and Ecuador’s energy sectors have shifted more. Still, hydrocarbon extractivism persists and focuses on more sustainable energy transitions occur concurrently with national plans for continuing and even increasing hydrocarbon extraction.

Leveraging perspectives of critical political economy, neo-extractivism, and dependency theories, this paper first explains the transformed landscape of relationships between key Western and Eastern IFIs and the states of Brazil and Ecuador as related to hydrocarbon-oriented (neo)extractivisms over time. Next, it develops the argument for how transformations in IFI-state relationships have also had consequences to the pursuit and form of (neo)extractivisms in both countries. To varying extents the Brazilian and Ecuadorian states have taken on a collaborative role in their relationships with IFIs, limiting the possibilities for fulfilling endogenous development, the socioeconomic promises of (neo)extractivism, and the commitment to shift from this development model. The differed positionalities of the two countries in the international political economy have resulted in unique arrangements. This argument is empirically formed through an examination of financial flows and conditions from IFIs as well as the relative role of hydrocarbons in the (neo)extractive development objectives of Brazil and Ecuador.



Mapping the Critical Zone: A New Era of Research in Artisanal and Small-Scale Mining

Sandra McKay

Queen's University, Canada

Artisanal and small-scale mining (ASM) is present in 80 countries across the global south, with an estimate of 40.5 million people working directly in this activity, and 150 million people dependent on this economic activity. This economic activity has garnered significant attention from the international development sector, both within academia and international policy spaces. The way in which ASM has been addressed by scholars in the academic literature, particularly the one from international development studies, has shifted over time, which in turn has influenced interventions that aim at governing this sector. Positioned as a Latin American scholar researching global development in Peruvian ASM, and with a particular focus on the newer body of literature coming from this region since 2018, in this literature review paper I synthesize insights from this region and bridge them with literature from other regions. I propose the classification of the contemporary literature on ASM into four distinct time periods: the Entrepreneurial Era (1970s-1990s), the Inclusionary Era (late 1990s - 2010s), the Formalization Era (2010s), and the Critical Era (2018-ongoing). In the second half of this paper, I delve into the Critical Era, where academic work explores the heterogeneity of this sector, contextualizes it within the global commodity chain, and critically evaluates the impacts of interventions that aimed to ‘fix’ this sector. With it, I propose new areas of research in ASM from a political ecology perspective that considers the intricate dynamics of ASM and the limits of the formalization policies.



Innovative Finance and Urban Dispossession: 'A Plan for Everyone for a Better Life' in Honduras

Karen Janet Spring

University of Ottawa, Canada

This paper examines the ways that innovative finance initiatives that aim to use public money to crowd in private sources of financing facilitate urban dispossession. We argue that innovative finance creates intricate webs of public-private relationships that make it difficult for communities affected negatively by development projects to seek redress, particularly in weak states with unaccountable governments. We focus on a case study from Honduras, where corrupt politicians used innovative financial vehicles such as a new security tax and trust funds formed by multistakeholder partnerships to enable urban dispossession: the construction of urban parks and recreation areas under the auspices of 'A Plan for Everyone for a Better Life' program (2010-2022).

 
1:30pm - 3:00pm2.3.3
Location: DS-1540
1:30pm - 3:00pm2.3.4 Teaching International Development Studies: Why and How to Integrate a Decolonial Lens
Location: DS-1545
 

Chair(s): John Cameron (Dalhousie University)

This panel will include a series of presentations and discussions about why and how to integrate a decolonize lens when teaching International Development Studies courses.

One of the things that I find so interesting about many of the proposed discussions is the emphasis on the areas of focus that Alex has identified as potential gaps in teaching so it would be good to then turn to recent approaches to decolonize development studies with some reflections from others on the panel including:

2. Andy Paras - and her new course on 'Decolonizing Development'

3. Ajay Parasram - and his reflections on the new course they've developed at Dalhousie on 'Racism and Development' (taught by Ajay Parasram), and new 4th year capstone course (also taught by Ajay), and their ongoing discussions about decolonization of IDS,

4. Laura Parisi to talk about how her experiences teaching gender and intersectionality in IDS.

 

Presentations of the Symposium

 

A Review of IDS Syllabi and Strategies to Integrate a Decolonial Lens

Alexandra Wilson
University of Ottawa

A Review of IDS Syllabi and Strategies to Integrate a Decolonial Lens

 

Reflections on a New Course on Decolonizing Development

Andrea Paras
Guelph University

Reflections on a New Course on Decolonizing Development

 

Reflections on a New Course on Racism and Development

Ajay Parasram
Dalhousie University

Reflections on a New Course on Racism and Development

 

Decolonizing the IDS Syllabus?

Georgina Alonso1, Adrian Murray2, Jess Notwell3
1University of Ottawa, 2University of Johannesburg, 3King's University College

Conversations in Decolonizing IDS: Process, Obstacles and Opportunities

Over the past few years, several members of the CASID executive and community have facilitated the creation of an accessible living online resource, entitled “Decolonizing the International Development Syllabus.” Our contribution to this panel will discuss this resource and encourage the CASID community to continue critically reflecting upon and discussing our collective encounters with the harms of IDS, the ways in which we can address those problems, and the challenges and opportunities that we face in the pursuit of ‘decolonizing’ IDS.

 
3:00pm - 3:30pmBreak 2 Day 2
3:30pm - 5:00pmCASID AGM
Location: DS-R520 - Plenary Day 2
5:00pm - 8:00pmCASID Social

Following the AGM, we invite you to join us for some complimentary snacks at L’Amere à boire, just a short 10-minute walk from UQAM. 

Date: Friday, 14/June/2024
8:30am - 10:00am3.1.1: Dissecting policy: what is working, what is not?
Location: DS-1520
Session Chair: Fiona MacPhail
 

Using Research for Building and Disseminating Evidence for Advocacy and Policy Adaptation

Linda Jane Liutkus

Plan International Canada, Canada

Despite global commitments progress in universalizing PPE has been slow and uneven. Research has found that more than half of all pre-primary aged children in conflict and emergency-affected countries have no access to quality PPE. Plan International’s LEARNPlus project is focusing on adopting an evidence-based, gender-responsive accelerated PPE model to meet the needs of children in underserved communities. Focusing on adapting, testing, and scaling an accelerated school readiness (ASR) program in Tanzania, Laos, Cambodia. Running since 2021, it is funded by the Global Partnership for Education Knowledge and Innovations Exchange (GPE-KIX) and the International Development Research Centre (IDRC). Testing the viability of contextualized, accelerated and enhanced PPE models as alternative, interim, cost-effective programs to support the expansion of PPE for children with limited access who are about to enter Grade 1. The project is using research to build evident to share with Ministries of Education to advocate for scale-up and policy adaption in a sustainable manner.

The project is using a Summer Pre-Primary (SPP) model originally developed for disadvantaged Turkish and Syrian refugee children. It was contextualized for Laos and further adapting for piloting in Cambodia and Tanzania, the adapted SPP model has been building research, undertaken Gender and Inclusion Assessments as well as Implementation Research. The results have helped inform the project stakeholders further refine the adapted SPP models. Following roll-out of the program, an impact study was done, using a strict Random Control Trial (RCT) to assess program quality, as well as a costing study to determine cost-effectiveness. The findings and recommendations of these studies have been used to develop policy documents, advocacy briefs, case studies, etc. The evidence generated through research is leading to advocacy with key national stakeholders on adopting and scaling the model to unserved areas and continue to make progress toward achieving SDG 4.2.



Investment Promotion and Governance in Sub-Saharan Africa: A Cross-Sectional Policy Analysis

Steffi Hamann

York University, Canada

Although the African continent has long been an integral part of the global economy, industrialization and manufacturing south of the Sahara are due to experience a veritable boom in the 21st century. Governments across sub-Saharan Africa have initiated major reforms to position themselves as competitive investment destinations. Although most analysts agree that private-sector investments play a crucial role in driving economic growth, investment promotion efforts in Africa give rise to controversial debates. Do they foster sustainable development, or do they merely accelerate a modern-day scramble for the continent’s valuable resources, deepening the global inequality crisis? To allow for systematic empirical investigations, this study presents the results of a cross-sectional comparative analysis of investment promotion regimes in 46 African countries. It introduces a novel classification scheme that plots investment incentives and conditionalities in a two-dimensional matrix and serves to categorize national-level investment laws with respect to the investor benefits each country provides and the investor performance requirements they mandate in return. The paper concludes with a demonstration of the suitability of this matrix as an analytical tool to evaluate and compare the drivers and impacts of private-sector investment activities across sub-Saharan Africa and beyond.



Invisible and precarious: A scoping review of gender-based violence in agricultural streams of Canada’s Temporary Foreign Worker Program

Silvia Leonor Sarapura, Regan Zink, Margarita Fontecha, Nicole Cupolo, Charlotte Potter

University of Guelph, Canada

Temporary Foreign Agricultural Workers (TFAWs), sources of labour in Canada’s agricultural sector, experience complex vulnerabilities due to structural inequalities within the agricultural streams of Canada’s TFWP. The multiple, diverse, and intersecting social identities of TFAWs may compound to exacerbate or lessen vulnerabilities, including gender-based violence (GBV). Through a scoping review, this research contributes to the GBV conceptual and practical knowledge in Canada’s agricultural TFWP in Ontario, Quebec and British Columbia. Our search strategy returned 1,273 grey and academic articles, 128 of which were selected for full-text review. Of those, 62 sources met our criteria for data extraction and were reviewed using a Gender-Transformative Change and a Systems Thinking framework to examine how structures and institutions create and exacerbate inequalities between TFAWs while influencing the formation of systems’ structures which either promote or negate GBV. Despite recognition that the TFWP is highly racialized and gendered, much of the literature on TFAWs in Canada is gender-blind and there is limited discussion on GBV within the program. Existing discussion regarding gender in relation to the TFWP is limited to the gender binary and does not address 2SLGBTQI+ individuals, communities, or their experiences. Structural inequalities and power imbalances make TFAW workers vulnerable. They are disincentivized and have limited opportunity to report grievances including substandard living and working conditions, workplace injuries or health-related concerns, discrimination, violence, and abuse. Beyond the workplace, the TFWP also impacts the social relationships of workers, including family dynamics in the home country and social networks within the hosting communities in Canada. Their temporary condition and other social dimensions create a feeling of not belonging in Canada. TFWP national and transnational policies retain structural vulnerabilities and conditions. Existing support mechanisms for TFAWs are hindered by a patchwork legal approach, complaint-driven regulatory regime, limited enforcement practices, and barriers to accessing permanent residency.



(pre-recorded) Quand les obstacles structurel et culturel fragilisent les droits sociaux en Haïti. Étude de la stratégie nationale d’aide sociale de 2010 à 2025.

Jean Clarck Marc Charles

UNIVERSITE OTTAWA, Canada

Cette communication vise à montrer comment et pourquoi les déconnexions, contradictions, entre le plan stratégique du développement d’Haïti (ci-après PSDH : 2010-2030) et la stratégie nationale d’aide sociale (ci-après SNAS : 2012) contribueraient à la faible mise en œuvre des droits sociaux en Haïti. Dans un contexte post-séisme, les résultats mitigés des différents programmes de la stratégie nationale, nonobstant certaines avancées et leur inspiration des programmes des pays de l’Amérique du sud, s’expliqueraient en raison du fait que certains programmes ont été mis sous silence notamment celui des personnes handicapées et celui de la santé. De plus, cette communication permet de démontrer pourquoi et comment cette stratégie, souffrant d’un déficit d’innovation, s’inscrirait dans des programmes à très court terme rendant la situation sociale plus décevante où l’assistanat devient monnaie courante.

Parallèlement, cette communication vise, dans une perspective institutionnaliste, à analyser l’agentivité des gouvernements succédés, des discours et enjeux à travers des outils d’élaboration et d’institutionnalisation de la stratégie et des pratiques pertinentes. Si l’on s’accorde que les gouvernements qui se sont succédé, pour la plupart, souffrant d’une carence de légitimité et de capacité en raison de son inertie vis-à-vis des droits sociaux (obstacle culturels) et que l’économie haïtienne reste jusqu’ici failli, dépendante par rapport aux dynamiques internationaux (obstacles structurels), alors cette communication permet de comprendre pourquoi et comment les facteurs externes/internes contraignent ou contribuent à la mise en œuvre de la stratégie nationale.

Nous priorisons la triangulation car elle nous permet de faire ressortir toute la multidimensionnalité du phénomène, ainsi qu'à mettre en évidence et à compenser la faiblesse de chaque perspective, méthode et source. Elle est également importante en raison des différentes facettes du phénomène tels que, fragilité de l’État, dépendance de l’économie, vulnérabilité, pour une vue plus riche.

Cette communication s’inscrit dans le cadre de ma recherche doctorale.

 
8:30am - 10:00am3.1.2
Location: DS-1525
8:30am - 10:00am3.1.3 Extractivism, Security and Development in Africa
Location: DS-1540
 

Chair(s): Nathan Andrews (McMaster University), Phil Faanu (McMaster University, Canada)

Poor governance of extractive resources has long been acknowledged as a risk to human development and sustainable peace in primary commodity-producing countries across the Global South. There is evidence that natural resource extraction has played a significant role in maintaining structures of colonial inequity and armed violence in developing societies. This is largely incompatible with social justice due to its disastrous socio-economic and environmental consequences. This panel session aims to unpack the social, economic, and environmental injustices and conflict-related issues associated with Africa’s extractive industry and their overall influence on development. The intersections of dispossession, grievances, conflict, resistance, and general security dynamics of extractivism are unravelled. The scope of discussion covers the broader extractive industry – oil and gas and mining in the African continent. The panel discussions take a critical approach through theoretical and empirical lenses on extractive-related security issues (community-level grievances, conflict, protest, etc.), land dispossession, and displacement. The rationale is to underscore how conflict, violence, and general insecurity issues in the extractive industry undermine development and to contribute further to policy recommendations for sustainable extractivism in Africa.

 

Presentations of the Symposium

 

Security Movements in Extractive Spaces: Dispossession, Community-Level Grievance and Resource Conflicts in Ghana

Alhassan S. Saaka1, Augustine Gyan2
1McMaster University, 2University of Bayreuth

Grievances, conflict, and some new forms of security movements increasingly characterize the African extractive sector. This paper seeks to explore community-level grievances and the associated security movements in the extractive spaces in Ghana. The paper aims to critically examine the new forms of security movements as a form of natural resource governance in Ghana’s mining industry that contribute to community-level grievances and dispossession or otherwise. The paper aims to answer the following questions: How do the government’s security policies contribute to community-level grievances and dispossession? How is security conceptualized or understood in Ghana’s mineral extraction? Whose security? Do the security-related policies in natural resource governance influence other community-level security movements and grievances? Guided by these questions, the paper aims to conceptualize “new form security movements” in the extractive sector and the overall impact on community-level grievances and conflicts in Ghana's mining sector.

 

Symbolic of Conflict Resolution by Civilian Armed Groups in South Kivu

Falk Petegou, Christopher Huggins
University of Ottawa

It is common that civilian armed groups constitute an obstacle to peace. However, the study of their interference in the artisanal mining sector reveals that they sometimes participate in the resolution of conflicts between the actors who intervene there. What justifies this fact? Why do civilian armed groups intervene in local conflict resolution processes in relation to the small-scale mining sector? What can we deduce from this regarding their perception of the mining sector and local power? This paper studies the conflict resolution mechanisms put in place by civilian armed groups as a regulatory form of interference in the ASM sector in South Kivu. The paper leads to the idea that the methods of conflict resolution engaged by civilian armed groups are part of the order of the representations they have of the sector. The artisanal mining sector presents itself to them as the expression of property, of an identity which materializes through the concern to preserve its integrity. Thus, resolving conflicts means participating in the preservation of the mining sector. For this, beyond purely materialist analyzes of the interference of civilian armed groups, the sector presents itself as a space for sharing emotions, memories, successes, and conquests linked to the conflicts which forge the very idea of 'existing as an armed group. It is in this cosmogonic trajectory that we must understand the commitment of armed groups to resolve conflicts in the small-scale artisanal mining sector. The paper is original as it considers the mining sector as a cosmogonic universe in which the motivations of the actors who intervene in it make it possible to identify their degree of attachment. The corollary is that the mining sector presents itself as an institution of conflict, a point of reflection on the nexus of natural resources, conflicts, and armed groups

 

#Stop Galamsey: The Securitization Language of ASM in the Media and its Influence on Policy

Racheal Wallace
Carleton University

Artisanal and small-scale mining (ASM) as an economic activity is often described as a poverty-driven activity, and many participants depend on it for a livelihood. Over the years, particularly in Ghana, ASM has experienced an explosion of diverse participants with an increase in the persistence of illegal ASM (galamsey). Successive Ghanaian governments have often had an ambivalent relationship with ASM and its participants. But in 2017, this dynamic evolved when images of the polluted Pra River due to illegal Artisanal and Small-scale Gold Mining were disseminated nationwide across various media platforms. This would lead to the media campaign #Stop Galamsey, which would portray ASM as a menace to society. The government would classify it as a security threat and take a militarized approach to clamp down on galamsey activities. This study presents an overview of the role of the media in framing discourse on galamsey, its influence on the government's securitization approach and policies implemented towards ASM, and its impact on participants over the past few years.

 

Climate Change Adaptation in Small and Medium-sized Cities and Municipalities

Ama Kissiwah Boateng
University of Public Service, Budapest Hungary

The focus of scholarly interest regarding climate action in cities is on large-scale cities or even megacities (Bulkeley, 2013; Bulkeley, Castan Broto and Maassen, 2013). It highlights the importance of megacities and their prominence and leadership in climate change and sustainability. However, the attention surrounding megacities is overshadowing other urban centres, such as those in polycentric areas, since just 12% of all urban residents live in these cities. Given that half of all people who live in cities worldwide live in cities with 500,000 or more residents (DESA, 2015), it is critical to include these cities in discussions on climate change (Hoppe et al., 2016). This calls for more research to understand the potential of these small and medium-sized cities and municipalities. The study employs a multiple case study research design to enable a deeper understanding of the situational complexity across a diversity of urban forms and governance structures.

 
8:30am - 10:00am3.1.4 Gender, Security and Development (2)
Location: DS-1545
 

Chair(s): Rebecca Tiessen (University of ottawa, Canada)

In this second panel, we will have a second series of papers that address the themes of gender, security and development including reflections on the Research Network's Women, Peace and Security Symposium, local strategies for addressing conflict-related sexual violence in Uganda and Kenya, and women's economic security and the role of conditional cash transfers

 

Presentations of the Symposium

 

Reflections on the RN WPS Symposium: Taking Action to Address Gender Equality, Peace and Security

Lena Dedyuka
uOttawa

This presentation will provide an overview of some of the main findings from the RN WPS Symposium on "Taking Action to Address Gender Equality, Peace and Security".

 

The Emotionally and Intellectually Challenging Journey of Studying Women, Peace, and Security

Phuong Tran
uOttawa

This presentation will offer an overview of some of the current and future research priorities for "Taking Action to Address Gender Equality, Peace and Security" arising from the RN WPS Symposium.

 

Ending Sexual and Gender-based Violence (SGBV) in Crisis- and Conflict-affected Contexts: Effective Strategies and Persistent Barriers

Rebecca Tiessen
uOttawa

More than a third of the world's women face gender-based violence in their lifetime, and acts of sexual violence in conflict were reported in 19 countries in 2022 (StopRapeNow.com). Diverse forms of SGBV are increasingly reported in crisis- and conflict- affected communities (especially in refugee communities). Survivors of SGBV are often persecuted based on

political, ethnic or religious affiliations, or on sexual orientation or gender identity, requiring an intersectional and feminist lens. Successful strategies for ending- and mitigating the impacts of- SGBV arise from the concerted

efforts of civil society organizations (CSOs), especially women-focused, loc

ally-based CSOs that have context-specific knowledge of

community-specific issues. Despite the important work carried out by these CSOs, their impacts are under-researched, and their challenges and barriers require further attention and analysis in relation to institutionalized

masculinities, patriarchal norms, and gender inequality. With increased attention to the role and impact of locally-based civil society organizations (CSOs) working to eliminate - and mitigate the impacts of - SGBV, we can better understand the opportunities for change, effective strategies, as well as the persistent challenges to ending SGBV. Additional research is therefore vital for documenting CSO programs and strategies:

their strengths, innovations and ongoing barriers.

 

Conditional Cash Transfers and their Impacts on Women in Nigeria

Nnenna Okoli
uOttawa

This presentation examines conditional cash transfer (CCT) programs in Nigeria, a sub-Saharan country where 63% of the population is multidimensionally poor and 41% experience monetary poverty (NBS, 2022). The program called the Household Uplifting Programme (HUP), was launched in 2016 to help poor households to improve their consumption, nutrition, education, and livelihood. Though implemented across every state in the country, knowledge of the HUP is still in its infancy because the program has barely been subjected to extensive systematic inquiry, especially from a gender perspective. While the theoretical underpinnings, impact, and morals of CCTs have been the subject of extensive empirical inquiry, far less attention has been paid to how the program which is inextricably linked to women, impacts women. Women’s voices need to be prioritized to uncover the drawbacks and strengths in the design and implementation of CCTs as they relate to their dignity and prosperity. For the HUP to cause positive change in women’s lives, it must go beyond women’s participation and inclusion to address the structures that drive unequal gender relations and women’s oppression at various levels.

 
10:00am - 10:30amBreak 1 Day 3
10:30am - 12:00pm3.2.1: Epistemic (in)justice
Location: DS-1520
 

Epistemic Justice and the Knowledge Commons

Chair(s): Prachi Srivastava (Western University, Canada)

Critical and radical analyses view ‘development’ as propagated via colonial modernist agendas predicated on an evolutionary societal model in which ways of being, living, and knowing and their organisation into forms (systems) of the centres of colonial power were made aspirational and obligatory for colonised peoples. This relied on exalting knowledge systems and knowledges of proclaimed colonial centres of enlightenment by ignoring, subjugating, and obliterating existing, traditional, and ancient knowledge systems and knowledges through ‘epistemicide’, or the annihilation of Indigenous and Southern knowledges (Hall & Tandon, 2017). ‘Development’ hinged on ‘cognitive imperialism’ (Battiste, 2018) and the disappearance of knowledges, rooted in violence (McKittrick, 2021).

Exalted knowledge systems and knowledges have been positioned in dominant discourse and international development architecture as those of ‘Western’/high-income OECD countries; and those in need of ‘development’, as of the majority world. Critical discursive views expose this dualistic characterisation as the product of colonial enterprises affixing the centrality of the perspective, according to Stuart Hall’s ([1993], 2018) classic formulation, of ‘the West and the Rest’, propagated by myths of relational superiority of ‘the West’. This is furthered by the construction and legitimisation of particular knowledges and knowledge regimes as taken for granted and valued and explicitly organised into formal education systems and taught, thus, becoming dominant.

Increasingly, there are calls for epistemic justice as part of a global project to realise social justice. This panel addresses specific aspects of epistemic justice relevant to research and practice. Epistemic justice is seen to rest on the right to knowledge, or ‘the right of every people to their own knowledge and ways of generating, legitimizing and valuing it, as well as the right of everyone to the knowledge of humankind’ (Schmelkes, 2023), i.e., the active participation in the creation of the knowledge commons and to access and transform it.

 

Presentations of the Symposium

 

Reconceptualizing violence in international and comparative education: revisiting Galtung’s framework

Julia Paulson1, Leon Tikly2
1University of Saskatchewan, 2Bristol University

Outside of a specialist literature, the study of violence occupies a marginal position within comparative and international education scholarship. A key contributing factor is the absence of a holistic conceptual framework that can capture the nature, extent and causes of violence in education. The article proposes such a framework, by updating Johan Galtung’s model of direct, structural and cultural violence and putting it into dialogue with more recent theoretical work from the social sciences and humanities, including ideas of epistemic violence. This dialogue affirms the importance of each form of violence and the interconnections between them but proposes a deeper appreciation of the depth ontology of violence and a reappraisal of Galtung’s ideas about the visibility and invisibilization of violence. The article explores the utility of the framework by using it to explore the so-called learning crisis, which it argues may be more accurately considered a crisis of violence.

 

Why is epistemic humility for epistemic justice provocative? A reflexive assessment

Prachi Srivastava
Western University

This paper puts forward epistemic humility as an explicit acknowledgement of the limits of knowledge – in time and in fact – and the socio-political and historical contexts within which knowledges are framed and legitimised. It posits epistemic humility from a Freirean perspective to be essential to consciously and critically engaging in processes of collective questioning with the aim to reach epistemic justice. Inspired by McKittrick’s (2021) radical approach to rupture dominant ways of scientific presentation in form and content, the paper uses reflexive stories and storytelling to ‘signal the fictive work of theory’ (p. 7). It recounts the author’s experiences of presenting the concept of epistemic humility for epistemic justice in high-level international fora, and asks the question, ‘Why is epistemic humility provocative, and for whom?’ In so doing, it promulgates epistemic humility as necessary to engage with transformational processes of discomfort to critically question one’s own normative positionalities, and to decentre and deconstruct long-held views and institutionalised structures of relational superiority of dominant knowledge systems.

 

Re-storying the university: reclaiming epistemic justice through liminal spaces of unlearning

Katherine Blouin1, Girish Daswani2
1University of Toronto Scarborough, 2University of Toronto Scarborogh

Not dissimilar from Edward Said’s concept of Orientalism, ‘epistemic violence’ becomes productive through consent and within institutions of learning and agreed-upon conventions and codes of understanding. Many of our disciplines are products of expert knowledge forged through the fires of colonialism and settler-colonialism and continue to harbour the embers of violence and exclusion. Such academic violence takes place through the wilful occlusion or the absent presence of certain histories and geo-political realities. If within one university multiple university worlds coexist, how do we speak back to the systemic occlusions of settler colonialism and the neoliberal story of individualized success? Through a discussion of some of the work done by Everyday Orientalism and University Worlds, this talk will examine how public-facing platforms can become loci where epistemic justice can be reclaimed in liminal spaces of unlearning, through enabling access to alternative stories and through deliberate acts of disruption that are necessary to create the world that we want to get to someday.

 

Reimagining knowledge mobilization: Confronting epistemic (in)justice and our carbon-constrained futures

Blane Harvey, Ying-Syuan Huang
McGill University

Academic and professional conferencing have long been seen as crucial sites for establishing, expanding, and mobilizing specialist knowledge to address pressing global challenges. They are also important sites for building membership in specific epistemic communities, particularly for new members to these communities, such as early career scholars. Conferencing practices, however, also tend to reinforce the same inequities and knowledge hierarchies that have characterized academia. Further, with the growing awareness of how fly-in, fly-out conferencing contributes to the climate crisis, we are now confronted with a double challenge of reimagining knowledge mobilization and knowledge exchange practices that are at once more equitable and more sustainable. This paper shares lessons and findings from a design-based research initiative aimed at testing responses to this double challenge through a global climate change adaptation conference held in Montreal in 2023. It highlights the opportunities, but also the deeply ingrained barriers to transforming processes of global knowledge exchange in academia and beyond.

 
10:30am - 12:00pm3.2.2: Focus on Canada
Location: DS-1525
Session Chair: Lina Aburas Awadalla
 

Exploring Entrepreneurship Opportunities Among Immigrant Women in Brandon, Manitoba

Shirlyn Minoja Kunaratnam

Brandon University, Canada

This study examines women entrepreneurship among immigrants in Brandon, Manitoba, Canada from a gender and development theoretical perspective. Every community has its uniqueness and challenges. Understanding the nature and character of a landscape is crucial for developing it effectively. This concept is same when it comes to rural immigration as well. In that sense exploring Brandon and its pressing need for economic growth is essential, especially with an increasing number of immigrants choosing Brandon as their home from 2007 onwards. However, Brandon being new to immigration and being one of the emerging rural cities has its challenges and needs in terms of providing suitable employment opportunities. The immigrants coming under different migration categories bring unique skill sets that can be utilized to for rural economic revitalization. In this context, the study takes a focused approach, centering on women immigrants. It explores how their distinct skill sets and entrepreneurial aspirations can play a fundamental role in starting businesses in Brandon, thereby contributing significantly to the overall economic development of the region. This study is structured into four main components: Firstly, this study focuses on identifying the challenges and needs of immigrant women who are entrepreneurial-oriented. Secondly, it explores the opportunities available in Brandon either to start up their businesses individually or as a group collectively. Thirdly the study will explore an ideal economic model for long-term sustainability. Finally, this study also will look into educational accreditation obstacles that hinder women from pursuing entrepreneurship and how it can be addressed.



The Road to Internationalization is Paved With Good Intentions: Ethical Dimensions of Internationalization in Ontario's Community Colleges

Christopher Duncanson-Hales

Canadore College, Canada

Having recently transitioned from a teaching role in universities to a position in international engagement and education within the Ontario community college system, I bring a unique perspective to the 2024 CASID Conference's themes of colonialism, decolonization, and migration.

This paper critically analyzes the ethical dynamics of international student mobility from the Global South, focusing on the implications for Ontario institutions that claim to practice ethical internationalization. International student mobility has become a pathway for talent transfer from developing to developed countries, inadvertently reinforcing global inequality and brain drain.

Drawing on Stein et al.’s (2019) international development ethics frameworks, and the “Brampton Charter for Improving the International Student Experience,” this paper argues that amid the benefits, internationalization also carries ethical burdens. Specifically, Ontario’s growing financial dependence on international student tuition revenue to subsidize public funds, coupled with the resulting brain drain from developing countries, fundamentally contradicts principles of ethical internationalization and the equity-based sustainable development principles embedded in the UN SDGs that Ontario colleges have endorsed and pledged commitment to.

This paper argues that community colleges must consciously evaluate how certain internationalization policies and practices undermine their institutional responsibilities as public bodies to promote collaborative global partnerships over self-interest, particularly in light of the perpetuation of socioeconomic inequities.

This paper's critical engagement with the ethical dimensions of internationalization practices in Ontario's community colleges, aims to thoughtfully contribute to ongoing discussions and advocacy efforts for more socially-conscious, equitable, and globally-responsible internationalization policies – policies centered on true partnership rather than exploitation.



Negotiating Identities in Development: Experiences from the Second-Generation Tamil Diaspora in Canada

Akalya Kandiah

McMaster University, Canada

International development has been criticized for having unequal power dynamics threaded through it, particularly those which stem from racist ideologies that have underscored development since its foundations. While racist ideas such as the “backward” or “tragic” south, in conjunction with notions of white saviourism contribute to these unequal power dynamics, the explorations of racism in development have largely revolved around understandings of the relationships between those carrying out development initiatives and the communities of the development sites. However, the rise of South-South cooperation and diasporic development have highlighted a need to understand racism from within the development sector itself. What are the experiences of racialized diasporic individuals and groups as they seek to engage in development initiatives from Turtle Island/Canada? Using in-depth interviews, this paper explores the nuances of “engaging in development” for racialized communities living in the Global North, such the second-generation of the Tamil diaspora in Canada. The development experiences of this group highlight the ways in which racialization and identity are salient development work, as well the colonial power dynamics that are negotiated by those engaged in diasporic development.



International education, migration and contemporary overlapping crises: examining Mexican and Vietnamese students’ temporalities in Canada’s edu-gration system

Anne-Cécile Delaisse, Maria Cervantes

The University of British Columbia - Occupational Science and Occupational Therapy, Canada

In Canada, immigration is envisioned as a way to support economic development, especially in the context of the labor force shortage ‘crisis’. International students are often considered “ideal candidates” for permanent residency (Desai Trilokekar & El Masri, 2019) and Canadian policies aimed at their recruitment and retention as skilled immigrants has been conceptualized as "edugration" (Brunner, 2022). However, many international students come from ‘developing’ countries, such as Mexico or Vietnam, that are themselves seeing major brain drain and lacking skilled labor force. This paper compares Mexican and Vietnamese international students’ and graduates’ migration decision-making while navigating the Canadian ‘edugration’ system. While this system offers a linear pathway to permanent residency for international students, this pathway has a delimited temporal framework; we argue that this does not always align with the temporality of international students’ and graduates’ plans and aspirations. We draw from 21 interviews conducted with 15 Mexican students and 6 graduates as well as 24 interviews with 10 Vietnamese students and 11 graduates. Our findings highlight participants' migration strategies for transnational social mobility, from childhood to post-graduation (including during the covid ‘crisis’). These strategies evolve uniquely over time, influenced by the region of origin and shaped by the dynamic socio-economic environments in both Mexico and Vietnam. Rather than embracing the homogenizing edugration time frame, this paper shows that there is a need to emphasize international students’ and graduates’ own temporality to foster a nuanced and critical understanding of their migration pathways and their compatibility with Canada’s immigration goals.

 
10:30am - 12:00pm3.2.3 La gestion des risques et de la sécurité : un nouveau paradigme pour les organisations canadiennes qui ont des opérations internationales?
Location: DS-1540
 

Chair(s): François Audet (Université du Québec à Montréal), Olivier Arvisais (Université du Québec à Montréal), Catherine Viens (Observatoire canadien sur les crises et l'action humanitaires, Canada)

Les crises d’origines anthropiques ou naturelles qui frappent les régions du monde forcent les organisations à veiller à faire une mise à jour en temps réel sur leur contextes opérationnels. Les menaces évoluent rapidement : changement climatiques, extrémisme violents, groupes criminel et armées, ou cybercriminalité, voilà les défis auxquels sont confronté les états et les organisations internationales. Ce panel vise à mobiliser des réflexions théoriques et empiriques sur des notions comme l’obligation de diligence, les seuils de tolérance au risque, les analyses des menaces. Il cherche notamment à répondre à certaines des questions suivantes : Comment s’effectue aujourd’hui les analyses de risques au sein des organisations? Comment sont internaliser les meilleurs pratiques au sein des organisations? Comme est appliqué l’obligation de diligence dans les contextes à haut risque? À l’intersection des disciplines qui s’intéressent à ces questions, telles que la théorie des organisations et la gestion de projet, ainsi que l’étude des relations internationales et de la gestion des risques et de la sécurité, ce panel propose des interventions basées à la fois sur la théorie et la pratique et émergent des travaux de l’Observatoire canadien sur les crises et l’action humanitaires (OCCAH).

 

Presentations of the Symposium

 

Modèle de gestion des risques et de la sécurité de l’OCCAH basé sur l’obligation de diligence : l’exemple des institutions académiques au Québec

François Audet1, Christine Persaud2, David Morin3, Catherine Viens2
1Université du Québec à Montréal, 2Observatoire canadien sur les crises et l'action humanitaires, 3Université de Sherbrooke

La reconnaissance de l’obligation de diligence (Duty of care) exige désormais des organisations qui déploient du personnel à l’étranger qu’elles protègent et informent leurs employés des risques encourus lors ces séjours. Depuis 2015, l’OCCAH a mis en place un programme de gestion des risques et de la sécurité. Élaboré en fonction des meilleurs pratiques et standards internationaux reconnus en matière de gestion des risques et de la sécurité, ce programme positionne l’observatoire comme un acteur clé dans l’émergence des nouvelles normes au Québec. Ce travail de co-coconstruction avec différentes organisations basées au Québec soulève plusieurs questionnements, à la fois théoriques et empiriques, sur les défis qui émergent de la triangulation de la réalité organisationnelle avec les enjeux juridiques et pratiques de l’obligation de diligence. En prenant l’exemple des institutions académiques québécoises, cet article met en dialogue l’expérience du programme de formation de l’OCCAH avec la littérature sur le duty of care qui s’intéresse aux obligations légales, éthiques et morales des organisations.

 

« Duty of care » ou « Duty of caring » ?

Caroline Coulombe, Jonathan Harvey
Université du Québec à Montréal

Après trois ans de pandémie de COVID-19, diverses recherches ont montré que plusieurs organisations n'étaient pas prêtes à faire face à une crise aussi longue et intense. Nous avons utilisé une analyse de cas unique de l'organisation à but non lucratif (ONG) Cambodia Living Arts (CLA) située au Cambodge, afin d'explorer et d'élargir le concept de « devoir de diligence » dans une organisation à but non lucratif exemplaire. Au fur et à mesure de l'analyse organisationnelle, nous sommes en mesure d'analyser les avantages et les défis liés à la création d'une transition organisationnelle bienveillante par le biais d'étapes importantes telles qu'une analyse régionale et internationale, l'élaboration de projections financières et la gestion des ressources humaines de la manière la plus humaine possible.

 

Seuils de tolérance aux risques à travers le prisme de la radicalisation et de l’extrémisme violent

David Morin
Université de Sherbrooke

Les causes multiples et les processus complexes de la radicalisation violente ont donné lieu à une littérature scientifique croissante au cours des dernières années, notamment dans les domaines psychologique et sociopolitique, qui reste toutefois inégale et lacunaire. L’état du risque et de la sécurité évolue rapidement et se détériore dans plusieurs pays du monde, forçant à adopter les meilleures pratiques pour réduire les risques lors de la planification et la réalisation de tous déplacements à l’étranger. Cette rapidité avec laquelle l’état de la sécurité se modifie implique nécessairement une actualisation, une adaptation constante et une vigilance accrue de la part des organisations de leurs seuils de tolérance aux risques. À travers le prisme de la radicalisation et de l’extrémisme violent, cette contribution soulève les enjeux et défis que ces phénomènes posent en termes d’analyse des menaces.

 

Quel design de résilience pour nos organisations face aux risques émergents et aux polycrises

Yannick Hémond
Université du Québec à Montréal

Dans un monde où les crises d'origines anthropiques et naturelles impactent de manière croissante les organisations, et ce, de multiples façons, il devient de plus en plus urgent d'adopter de nouvelles stratégies organisationnelles de résilience dans la gestion des risques. Les organisations ne peuvent plus seulement se protéger, elles doivent être proactives et mettre en place des actions d’adaptation concrètes pour faire face aux nombreuses conséquences en lien avec les changements climatiques, mais également les situations de conflits armés qui sévissent à travers le monde. La nécessité d'analyser les risques de manières dynamiques et d'intégrer de meilleures pratiques au sein des structures organisationnelles n’est donc plus à démontrer.

L'objectif est de proposer un design de résilience qui permette aux organisations de s'adapter et de prospérer dans un monde marqué par des risques émergents et des polycrises. Les organisations doivent non seulement être préparées à répondre aux défis actuels, mais aussi capables d'anticiper et de gérer efficacement la complexité inhérente aux risques émergents, aux interdépendances qui en découle ainsi qu’aux nombreuses conséquences.

 
10:30am - 12:00pm3.2.4: Food security and Indigenous perspectives
Location: DS-1545
Session Chair: Vida Shehada
 

Taking care of the land for food security: The Indigenous Planning of Quechua People in Peru

Silvia Leonor Sarapura Escobar

University of Guelph, Canada

Andean Indigenous food systems depend on community land use planning to maintain the genetic pool of crops and landraces in the face of climate change. These systems are managed integrally and based on indigenous knowledge of soil conservation, water management and biodiversity conservation. Food system research, policy and programming exhibit a limited understanding of indigenous systems planning and community and cultural contexts. In policy and programming, the treatment of communities as homogenous groups overlooks heterogeneity in local identities. The purpose of this article is to respond to this gap by shedding light on the intersecting identities of Andean peasant women and men who contribute to the sustainability and resilience of their agri-food systems. Our focus is on intersecting identities and planning processes. This study draws on intersectional feminist thinking, socio-ecological systems and resilience thinking to apply an intersectional lens to the study of planning processes in several Andean communities. Findings identify contributions around soil conservation, biodiversity upkeep, water management, and communal or cultural practices that are shaped by peasants' intersecting identities and their interactions within social-ecological systems. Findings illustrate the importance of multiple social locations, relations, and structures of power, including but not limited to gender, but other categories such as age and ethnicity for the delivery of equitable resilience. We formulate some initial recommendations for national approaches and interventions to better reflect the diversity of Andean people's identities and the way these affect relationships with socio-ecological systems in national and public planning. In particular, we suggest the value of exploring further the potential of rights-based approaches for enhancing equitable resilience in Andean agri-food systems.



Women’s challenges in indigenous knowledge food security in South Africa: The case of Alice in the Eastern Cape Province

Gabriel Acha Ekobi

University of Fort Hare, South Africa

Indigenous knowledge among women represents a valuable source of local solutions to food insecurity, most importantly, during food scarcities. However, there is a paucity of data on women’s challenges in indigenous knowledge food security in South Africa and Alice. The study aim is to explore women’s challenges in promoting indigenous knowledge food security in Alice. The study adopts a qualitative research approach and exploratory design to answer the objective. Twenty-five participants consisting of twenty-two women and three officials who work closely with the women will take part. Purposive sampling will be used to recruit participants and semi-structured interview guide will be employed to collect data from the participants. Data analysis is thematic and themes that will be identified are: indigenous knowledge know-hows and challenges faced by women. It is anticipated that challenges such as no land ownership, lack of finance, lack of proper training and insecurity plague women. Young people (women) are shying away from indigenous knowledge and food production because they see it as archaic. The study concludes that these challenges are contributing in increasing food insecurity and poverty incidence. Workshops and seminars could be organized to train and educate women in indigenous knowledge and food security as this might mitigate the challenges.



The political economy of agroecological transitions

Ben McKay1, Georgina Catacora-Vargas2, Ryan Nehring3

1University of Calgary, Canada; 2Professor of Agroecology, Academic Peasant Unit “Tiahuanacu” of the Bolivian Catholic University; 3Associate Research Fellow, International Food Policy Research Institute

Agroecological transitions are fraught with challenges. Not only are there structural and institutional barriers or ‘lock-ins’ that uphold an unsustainable global food system, agroecological transitions require rethinking how we work with ecosystems and involve a shift in productive and reproductive relations in agriculture. By problematizing prevalent relations in conventional agro-commodity production, agroecology seeks to shift control over the labour process and value appropriation, while working to repair epistemic and metabolic rifts by prioritizing farmers’ knowledge and strengthening the co-production of human and non-human nature. But what are the factors that may facilitate or restrict agroecological transitions? Using a political economy approach, we put forth five key interrelated dimensions for analyzing agroecological transitions: (i) social metabolism; (ii) labour dynamics; (iii) markets and resources; (iv) social organizations; and (v) policies and politics. We argue that these key dimensions offer analytical and political utility for examining the political economy of agroecological transitions and can be used to both address gaps and complement existing frameworks.

 
12:00pm - 1:30pmLunch Day 3
1:30pm - 3:00pm3.3.1: Ecological perspectives: water system governance, weather preparedness and 'the feminization' of agriculture
Location: DS-1520
 

Examining the ‘feminization of agriculture’ among small-scale farming households living in complex socio-ecological systems in San Marcos, Guatemala

Emily Kocsis, Joshua Garcia-Barrios, Warren Dodd

University of Waterloo, School of Public Health Sciences

In rural Guatemala, small-scale farming is increasingly untenable due to factors such as conflict and violence, stagnant wages, land grabbing, the presence of agribusiness, and the challenges posed by climate change. As a result, high levels of out-migration from rural spaces is occurring across the region, primarily by men in search of better economic opportunities. This socio-demographic shift - termed the “feminization of agriculture” - is associated with women being ‘left behind’ on the farm to navigate changing productive and reproductive responsibilities, decision-making and community dynamics. This research aims to understand how the lives and livelihoods of rural women are impacted by the complex, and often contradictory effects of male out-migration, with an attentiveness to how this transition influences health and wellbeing outcomes. Grounded in feminist political ecology (FPE), we sought to understand how the ‘feminization of agriculture’ affects individuals, households, and communities in overlapping ways. Collaborating with a local non-governmental organization, we conducted semi-structured interviews, key informant interviews, and participant observation with 73 individuals in Tojchoc Grande, San Marcos. Informed by the domains of the Women’s Empowerment in Agriculture Index (WEIA), collected data included demographic information, assets, gender roles in agricultural activities and decision-making, as well as perceptions and experiences of wellbeing. A key finding of this research is that rural outmigration impacts women’s roles in agriculture and related activities, which affects productivity and gender equity. In Tojchoc Grande, the feminization of agricultural labour and management has myriad drawbacks; women are doubly burdened by missing on and off-farm labour, end up with less time for leisure and socializing, and face more socioeconomic, physical, and psycho-social health challenges. Opportunities exist for social and policy interventions to leverage women’s increased role in farming, however, generalized state abandonment and minimal social support are entrenching and feminizing agrarian distress.



Perspectives of local water system governance and health among various stakeholders in a Western Highland community of Guatemala

Joshua Garcia-Barrios, Emily Kocsis, Brian Laird, Warren Dodd

Univeristy of Waterloo, School of Public Health Sciences

Stable and secure water systems are critical for health, wellbeing, and local economic development among small-scale farmers in rural Guatemala. However, water systems in the Western Highlands are highly vulnerable to climate change and other socio-ecological disturbances. In this context, this study aimed to describe diverse stakeholder perspectives on local water system governance in relation to users' health and community wellbeing in a Western Highland community. In partnership with local NGOs, we conducted semi-structured interviews with small-scale farmers (n=25), local water managers (n=10) and healthcare workers (n=5) in Tojchoc Grande, San Marcos. Perspectives of local water governance differed between small-scale farmers, water managers and healthcare workers. Although farmers held positive views toward available water resources for supporting overall health, water managers and healthcare workers had concerns of water-borne illness, poor water system and healthcare funding, and inadequate system capacity to meet community needs. Further, water managers and healthcare workers expressed confusion over organizational jurisdication of water and public health resources. However, all stakeholders pointed to government corruption and the absence of state support as major contributors to local system weaknesses. Local development efforts aimed at improving water systems and community health should consider the long-lasting impact of decentralized natural resource laws enacted following the Guatemalan civil war. Critically, the downstream impacts of these laws and challenges surrounding system-level coordination and associated corruption issues may have consequences for local resource administration and community health. Further water monitoring research is needed to assess health risks connected to water use and consumption.



Examining extreme weather event preparedness, response, and recovery among community health workers in Negros Oriental, Philippines: A qualitative study

Bridget Beggs1, Lincoln Lau2,3, Laura Jane Brubacher1, Warren Dodd1

1University of Waterloo, Canada; 2University of Toronto, Canada; 3International Care Ministries, Philippines

Issue/objective: The Philippines remains one of the most vulnerable countries to extreme weather events, which will continue to increase in both frequency and severity. Community health workers (CHWs) often act as an important resource to deliver health-related support in resource-constrained settings during crises and may improve community adaptation amid disasters. In this context, the objective of this study was to examine experiences of extreme weather event preparedness, response, and recovery among CHWs across resource-constrained communities in Negros Oriental, Philippines.

Methodology: This study was conducted in partnership with International Care Ministries (ICM), a Philippines-based non-governmental organization. We conducted 51 semi-structured interviews with CHWs across four regions in Negros Oriental, Philippines.

Results: While most participants described challenges surrounding preparedness for extreme weather events within their community, many CHWs also commented on how their recent experience of Typhoon Odette (December 2021) contributed to disaster preparedness activities for subsequent threats. During recent disasters, most CHWs focused on taking care of their immediate family members; however, they also described the role of community cooperation when recovering from the impacts of these disasters. Further, CHWs expressed that their health-related training from ICM enhanced their capacity to respond to Typhoon Odette and share health education with other community members.

Discussion/conclusion: CHWs may be able to support community-based preparedness, response, and recovery efforts amid extreme weather events if provided with appropriate training and resources. However, efforts to equip CHWs to support communities amid extreme weather events need to consider the individual- and household-level impacts experienced by CHWs themselves.



Examining Implementer Experiences to Inform Scale-up of a Community Health Worker Program in the Philippines

Warren Dodd1, Laura Jane Brubacher1, Lincoln Lau2

1University of Waterloo, Canada; 2International Care Ministries, Philippines

Achieving the health-related Sustainable Development Goals will require scaling up promising community-based health interventions. Within the Philippines, International Care Ministries (ICM), a non-governmental organization, employs a network (1300 individuals) of volunteer community health workers (CHWs) to extend the reach of the health system into resource-constrained communities across the Visayas and Mindanao. In February 2023, ICM piloted a new iteration of this 'Community Health Champions' program in one province (Negros Oriental). The program aims to improve maternal and child health outcomes, as well as facilitate health care access among households experiencing poverty. A process evaluation of the implementation of the ‘Community Health Champions’ program was conducted to assess readiness for and inform scale-up across the Philippines. In total, 11 participatory focus groups (n=75 participants) and 64 semi-structured interviews were conducted with CHWs (program implementers) across six locations within Negros Oriental, Philippines. New intervention components introduced in the pilot program, including the provision of basic medical treatment facilitated through an mHealth app, were perceived to enhance the effectiveness and impact of CHWs in addressing maternal and child health needs. Pilot program implementation was further facilitated through the positionality of implementers, including their embeddedness within their communities and their pre-existing social connections (including collaboration with the public sector to provide quality care). The introduction of new intervention components also created new opportunity costs among implementers, as some participants perceived the pilot program as more time consuming and complex than their previous CHW work. The presence of supportive group spaces for training and learning, facilitated by CHW trainers, were perceived to enhance CHW confidence with new intervention components. Inclusion of implementer knowledge and insights within process evaluations of pilot programs can enhance understandings of how implementer characteristics may influence program scale-up.

 
1:30pm - 3:00pm3.3.2: Indigenous knowledge systems, perspectives, and contributions.
Location: DS-1525
Session Chair: Rebecca Tiessen
 

'Community Resilience and Memory Narratives among Weavers in a Country in Reconciliation

Laura Sarmiento

Saint Mary Universtity, Canada

This research explores community resilience among women affected by the Colombian armed conflict, concentrating on the "Artesanas de Amor" collective. Employing an Interpretivism epistemological stance and a constructivist ontological standpoint, the study acknowledges individuals' active role in shaping their realities. Thematic Analysis is chosen as the method to reveal patterns within the data.

The research begins by contextualizing the Colombian conflict, specifically in Eastern Antioquia, where the collective is situated. It then delves into the concepts of resilience, trauma, memory, and memory narratives. The chosen methodology emphasizes semi-structured interviews, participant observation, analysis of embroidery, and secondary data analysis. The subsequent data analysis aims to comprehend the construction of community resilience, how communities navigate conflict, and initiate growth and healing.

The focus is on the "Artesanas de Amor" collective, exploring the techniques aiding them in overcoming conflict and contributing to their embroidery project and healing process. The research seeks to understand community resilience and the role of memory narratives, with a particular emphasis on women's experiences. The study investigates trauma, collective memory, and artistic practices such as embroidery as tools for healing. The overarching goal is to offer insights into building community resilience in conflict-affected communities, providing valuable guidance for governmental and non-governmental institutions.



(pre-recorded) The Social Impacts of Retail Stores in the Inuvialuit Settlement Region.

Tamara Leanne Donnelly

University of Ottawa, Canada

In the Inuvialuit Settlement Region (ISR) of the the Northwest Territories (NWT), although wild-harvested foods remain central to the diet and culture of Inuit (Little et al., 2021) climate change (Johnston & Spring, 2021; Spring et al., 2018), the nutrition transition (Sharma et al., 2009), and the growing reliance on retail food (Luongo et al., 2020) have changed the landscape of diets within the region. This change of diets has resulted in a greater reliance on store-bought foods; however, prices of products from these stores are some of the highest in the country, coupled with the fact that the region has some of the lowest per capita income (Kenny, Fillion, et al., 2018). My research narrow in on Paulatuk, a Hamlet of approximately 300 people in the ISR. My masters thesis work has been to conduct talking circles and interviews to demonstrate how monopolies of grocery stores affect Indigenous communities through more than just limited food options, my research shows that this goes further, into community relationships and stress, effecting the everyday well-being of community members. A community the has been effected by issues such as residential schools and often over-looked by Southern Canada; community members feel the effects of high-food prices and it was stated that it seems like Southern companies are taking advantage of their precarity and remote location. In sum, my paper looks at the impacts the grocery store has in Paulatuk, looking at issues Indigenous communities face and the food insecurity in the region.



Land, worldview, culture: Impacts and dynamics of change within Indigenous Knowledge Systems

Charlotte Potter, Silvia Sarapura

University of Guelph, Canada

As climatic and environmental changes threaten access and production of food globally, scholars have increasingly looked to non-Western, Indigenous or local food systems to provide solutions and strategies for mitigation and resilience. Recognition is widespread of the importance of Indigenous Knowledge (IK) for attaining local and global food security, however IK systems underpinning local food systems remain poorly understood within academic scholarship, often represented in the binary and reductionist categories of ‘Indigenous knowledge’ and ‘western science’. Increasing voice and representation by IK holders in research settings has challenged the conception of non-western knowledge as simply ‘local’ or ‘Indigenous’ by illustrating that all knowledge is situated, socially constructed, hybrid, and shaped by the specific contexts of knowledge holders. As social, political, economic and ecological environments change, ways of knowing also change. To understand, work with, and support the continuation of Indigenous knowledge systems which inform food systems, non-Indigenous scholars need to understand the factors that influence the changing and adaptation of these systems, acknowledging their hybridity and fluidity. This scoping review of academic literature on Indigenous food systems knowledge uses systems thinking to understand this fluidity by identifying the elements that construct knowledge, analyzing how these elements support and are supported by food systems practices. This review identifies ‘Land’, ‘Worldview’, and ‘Culture’ as central intersecting elements which define and construct IK systems supporting local food systems. Impacted by diverse factors across varying levels of influence, this review analyzes how events, patterns, systems structures and mental models trigger change within knowledge systems and how this impacts local food systems, and identifies leverage points with the greatest impact. By understanding how factors at different levels impact actors and elements in IK systems, this review argues that stronger community collaborations and more effective interventions which address root causes of food unsecurity may be possible.



Indigenous knowledge and conflict resolution: A literature review

Lena Dedyukina

University of Ottawa, Canada

Indigenous approaches to conflict resolution encompass several crucial points that must be acknowledged, accepted, and respected as fundamental elements for fostering peaceful coexistence between Indigenous and non-Indigenous peoples. Given the existing gap in the academic literature concerning Indigenous conflict resolution practices in the North American context, this literature review aims to provide an overview of the current work on Indigenous conflict resolution practices worldwide. The implementation of Indigenous conflict resolution practices is not only desirable but also necessary as a step toward Indigenous self-determination, self-governance, and the decolonization of conflict resolution practices. The relationality of Indigenous conflict resolution mechanisms provides a distinct perspective of Indigenous identity as a multiplicity of all relationships based on autonomy as a significant aspect of self-governance. Rituals, ceremonies, and emotions in conflict resolution processes are critical components and integral parts of restorative justice. At the same time, relation to the Land, water, and other non-human species cannot be avoided as they are part of the conflict resolution process from an Indigenous perspective. The history of treaty relationships and current debates around reconciliation provide an additional layer to the analysis. There is a need to recognize Indigenous Ways of Knowing and Being as fundamental elements in the peacebuilding process with diligence to avoid romanticizing Indigenous approaches to conflict. Indigenous conflict resolution practices can enrich the academic field of study and address the existing gap in North American academic literature and the practice contributing to the development of new approaches to complex issues.

 
1:30pm - 3:00pm3.3.3
Location: DS-1540
1:30pm - 3:00pm3.3.4: Decolonial Disability Studies and Overlapping Global Crises: Transcending Traditional Development Intervention and Epistemic Paradigms
Location: DS-1545
 

Decolonial Disability Studies and Overlapping Global Crises: Transcending Traditional Development Intervention and Epistemic Paradigms

Chair(s): Karen Soldatic (Toronto Metropolitan University)

Responding to this year’s CASID conference theme of overlapping global crises, each of the panelists in this proposed roundtable tackles one of the three sub-themes as follows: (1) “Theoretical and empirical examinations of colonialism, imperialism, and decolonization,” (2) “International solidarities, liberation and abolition,” and (3) “Human rights abuses, gender inequality, racisms, and discrimination and marginalization according to social relations of oppression…” We do so by elevating intersectional decolonial disability studies as an alternative epistemic and intervention stance in connection to oppressive underdevelopment and (mis)representation issues impacting intersectional disability groups in global south contexts. Our innovative theoretical framing builds on two concomitant bodies of literature: the coloniality of power (Quijano, 2000), knowledge (Dussel, 1995), and being (Maldonado-Torres, 2007) on the one hand, and critical disability studies (CDS) with an emphasis on alternative (Goodley et al., 2019) and intersectional (Obourn, 2020) explorations within global north contexts or, most significantly, explorations which target global (Erevelles, 2011) and global south/development concerns (Grech, 2015; Meyers, 2019) on the other. Our proposal stems from the limited attention given to disability matters in development studies, despite its status as the largest global minority whose future is closely entangled in most overlapping crises worldwide. Our analysis synthesizes themes and findings from curating a special issue on decolonial disability in the global south which will be published at the end of the spring through the Review of Disability Studies. Our cluster of essays demonstrate the need not only to give agency to impacted intersectional disability populations. Above all, these works stress the need to critically interrogate the innovative epistemic complexities highlighted whenever one seeks to undo the injustices and oppressive dimensions at the root of the extreme marginalization to which these groups are subjected.

 

Presentations of the Symposium

 

.

Alexis Padilla1, Xuan Thuy Nguyen2, Shilpaa Anand3
1University of Missouri Saint Louis, 2Carleton University, 3Department of Humanities and Social Sciences at the BITS-Pilani Hyderabad Campus

.

 
3:00pm - 3:30pmBreak 2 Day 3
3:30pm - 5:00pm3.4.1: Sustainable Development Goals; Refugee livelihoods through education
Location: DS-1520
Session Chair: Rebecca Tiessen
 

Building sustainable and decent refugee livelihoods through education? Interplay between policies and realities of five refugee groups in Global South

Preeti Dagar

University of Glasgow, United Kingdom

Contrary to common assumptions, the vast majority of the world’s refugees reside in neighbouring countries in the Global South, where they struggle to find quality education and opportunities for decent livelihoods. UNESCO’s Global Monitory Report (2019) and UNHCR’s Global Framework for Refugees (2019) stress strengthening vocational and entrepreneur skills for employment generations, empowerment, and decent work.

This paper explores the underexamined yet highly relevant interlinkage between sustainable livelihoods and education among urban refugees residing in three major cities in India. It speaks to the tight intersection of education, livelihoods and aspirations of five refugee communities: Afghan, Rohingya, Somali, Chin and Tibetan. Building on interviews, focus groups and participatory drawings from 66 refugees and staff respondents, it foregrounds the compounded interplay of skills development with intersectional oppression of refugees and their socio-political freedoms in navigating livelihoods and entrepreneurship avenues.

The research builds an evidence base for SDGs 4 and 8, addressing quality education and decent work. It further builds a bridge between these two SDGs and establishes the interconnectedness of these goals by examining the role of available educational opportunities in supporting decent and dignified work for refugees. Furthermore, the study foregrounds refugee voices and presents a comparative picture of refugee realities in India.

By bridging capabilities and sustainable livelihoods approach, the paper foregrounds the effects of race, gender, class, ethnic, and religious identities of refugees on their educational attainment, involvement, and utilisation. Theoretically, the paper advances capabilities account in refugee contexts by combining it with sustainable livelihoods to develop a deeper understanding of refugee lives and livelihoods. I argue that the idea of education and livelihoods for refugees should seek to move beyond the neoliberal agenda of self-employment and self-reliance and towards well-being, holistic development, and social integration.



Decentring the Sustainable Development Goals: Alternatives to reimagining desired shared futures.

Loretta Baidoo1, Kent Williams2, Alexander Davis3

1St. Mary's University, Canada; 2Acadia University; 3Mount Saint Vincent University

Nearing nine years after the introduction of the Agenda 2030 and the SGDs and efforts made to achieve these sustainable goals, there are still concerns about the ability to achieve sustainable development. Scholars interrogating the challenges conflating the achievement of the SDGs have attributed to factors such as lack of commitment, due to the abstract nature of the SDGs, insufficient awareness, and implementation structures at regional and local levels. The United Nations- implementing institution, is critiqued for operating within a world order which propagates a colonial and capitalist system, impacting commitment and ownership by persons primarily impacted by global crisis and inequalities in the Global South, Indigenous and racialized communities. In addition, the westernization of efforts around the SDGs is enumerated to account for the crisis of understanding and appreciation of the issues to be addressed at the community level. These arguments suggest that achieving the Agenda 2030 and its goals requires a more eclectic approach.

In recognition, this paper calls for a decentralized approach to SDGs with attention to both mainstream and alternative methodologies and responds to how the SDGs can be approached to ensure meaningful development for diverse contexts and identities. A conceptual review explores how, as a people, we might collectively enable inclusive and ethically diverse pathways to sustained futures. This is achieved by exploring a case study at Dalhousie University that employs the Brookings Institute’s 17 Rooms approach and two-eyed seeing. Based on findings from this case study, we conceptually explore how we can begin conversations on reimagining desired futures through decentring the SDGs in both conceptualization and implementation.



ANALYZING THE IMPACT OF THE SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT GOALS ON POVERTY, GENDER EQUALITY, AND CLIMATE CHANGE IN RURAL AFRICAN HOUSEHOLDS (2017-2022)

Yusuf Adebowale

Brandon University, Canada

The 2030 agenda for sustainable development, adopted by all United Nations member States in September 2015, provides a shared blueprint for prosperity and peace to strive among the people and all regions of the world. Many countries in the continent of Africa, despite the fact that they gained independence decades ago, do not prevent Africa from becoming dependent. Although the shift from colonization was full of hope with a brighter, rewarding future, it did not have a visible impact on the SDG goals, most especially efforts to deliver people from poverty and hunger, which are easily encouraged by undeterred corruption at all levels. It is obvious and well reported that many local, regional, and international institutions have supported the African continent to deal with poverty, gender inequality and forestall good livelihood of people and nations of Africa, discover and explore the individual, national and regional potentials making required contribution in the global community. This paper will evaluate the effect of the global goals on the African continent; the objective will be to determine the poverty (relationship between hunger and income) level, assess the impact of gender equality on sustainability, and the alarming effect of unsustainable consumption patterns in high-income countries on the climate crisis.

 
3:30pm - 5:00pm3.4.2
Location: DS-1525
3:30pm - 5:00pm3.4.3: Critical analysis from India on the Agrarian Social Movement, the 2008 Kandhamal violence, democracy and decentralization
Location: DS-1540
 

Authoritarian Neoliberalism Meets Agrarian Populism: Decoding the Agrarian Social Movement of 2020-21 in India

Paramjit Singh

York University, Canada

The three farm laws introduced by the BJP government in India in 2020 were a significant step toward strengthening the control of corporate monopolies on livelihood and food security issues of the majority of the rural population. Pro-people activists and intellectual sections effectively realised the severity of the government’s intention. It brought together all the peasant unions of Northern India to challenge the authoritarian and monopoly capital project of hijacking the agricultural production system and transforming farmers into the sub-contractors of corporate capital. The peasant movement forced the authoritarian government to repeal the three farm laws. The pro-people intellectual and activist circles globally celebrated this victory as a role model to challenge the authoritarian neoliberalism and corporate alliance. However, this article argues that this is only a temporary relief. Many important issues have remained unaddressed by the scholars and activists of the movement and need to be explored to examine the potential of such movements beyond a fight for the status quo.

The present paper will address four interrelated issues in light of these facts. First, it will unfold the authoritarian government’s politics of interlocking the rural population into the accumulation logic of global capital in the name of development. Second, it will examine the basis of unity among ideologically different (if not conflictual) organisations during the movement. Third, it will decode the politics of major farmers and other unions to bring out the limitations of their agenda for the resolution of the new agrarian question and, importantly, for socialist alternatives. Finally, it will highlight critical questions for the future politics of the left organisation from the perspective of the rural poor.



Decolonizing Memory in the National Imagination: A Critical Analysis of the 2008 Kandhamal Violence

Clara A.B. Joseph

University of Calgary, Canada

This paper reads the events known as the “2008 Kandhamal violence” to explore how and why decolonizing memory is fundamental to peace in the region. This incident is widely recognized as a “targeted violence against the Christian community in Kandhamal” (“Unjust Compensation” 2013), thus privileging the event as an instance of communalism or religious strife rather than an economic crisis. Murder, rape, arson, and looting left “54,000 people . . . homeless.” Through a close reading of the main events of this violence and critical analysis of sources—scholarly articles, media reports, and social media discussions—the paper proposes that there are three fundamental issues that cause “targeted violence against the Christian community” or the representation of an instance of violence as communalism in India and the manufacture of Christians of India as colonial leftovers: A) Being interpellated by ideology as “remembering.” That is, individuals are called or positioned by colonial ideologies, and their understanding of the world is shaped by these ideologies through a process that resembles remembering. Consequently, Christians of India are remembered as colonial products. B) Buying into the colonial narrative of the “civilizing mission” wholesale. This phrase refers to the act of unquestioningly accepting and adopting the ideas and justifications on Christianizing that colonial powers propagated during the colonial era. C) The need to decolonize memory in the national imagination. Historical narratives are often shaped by colonial perspectives that may marginalize or distort the experiences of indigenous or colonized peoples who happen to be Christians. Therefore, this is a call for reevaluating and reshaping the way historical events and narratives are remembered and represented within the context of a nation. The paper, in this manner, aims to inform scholars, policymakers, and activists committed to fostering peace and justice.



Backsliding of Democracy and Decentralization in Kerala (India)

Jos Chathukulam

Centre for Rural Management (CRM), Kottayam, Kerala, India

Human development and democratization characterized by public action have been the hallmarks of ‘Kerala model of development’. It has been celebrated as a unique successful model within India and across the world for its contribution and achievements in human development, reducing poverty, investment in public goods as well as for fostering vibrant civil societies and social capital since the 1970s. Similarly, Kerala model of decentralization, an offspring of the Kerala model of development, has also been hailed as one of the effective models in revolutionizing decentralization and devolution. The People’s Plan Campaign (PPC) of 1996, which spearheaded the Kerala model of decentralization has been likened to the Participatory Budgeting experiments undertaken in Porto Alegre in Brazil. While Kerala model of development has completed more than 50 years and Kerala model of decentralization have completed 25 years, the political hegemony of the Communist Party of India (Marxist) led Left Democratic Front (LDF) over these two “models” have led to the disintegration of development model and democratic decentralization. The ‘party society’ centered around Kerala model of development and the capture of local governments and its apparatuses have led to erosion of democratic spirit and democratic consensus in Kerala. Adversarial politics with a disruptive tenor has led to backsliding of democracy and decentralization in Kerala. The introductory part of the paper offers a brief profile of Kerala model of development and democratic decentralization. The second part discusses the factors that led to the backsliding of democracy and decentralization and its impact on the social fabric of Kerala. It is followed by a discussion and conclusion on ways to incorporate democratic framework and principles to critically revisit the Kerala model of development and decentralization.



The Role of Human Capital in Development: Examining the “Kerala Model” of Developmet

Joseph M Tharamangalam

Mount St. VincentUnversity, Canada

This paper examines the role played by Human Capital (HC) in the development path of the well-known “Kerala Model”, with a special focus on the ways in which Kerala’s HC helped to connect Kerala and its socio-economic system with the global socio-economic system. A small state in India, Kerala became known among scholars by the 1970s for its relatively high Human Development indicators despite low economic growth. While some scholars expressed serious concern about the sustainability of this “Kerala Model of Development”, with no productive base, Kerala not only sustained and even enhanced its HD achievements, but in just a few years began to achieve high economic growth as well, eventually becoming one of the richest Indian states , indeed with the highest per capita income and consumption. The paper argues that that Kerala’s high HC, its educated and skilled workforce (many migrating abroad and sending remittances home) played an important role. It concludes by suggesting that early investments in HC generally lead to sustainable economic and social development.

 
3:30pm - 5:00pm3.4.4
Location: DS-1545

 
Contact and Legal Notice · Contact Address:
Privacy Statement · Conference: CASID 2024
Conference Software: ConfTool Pro 2.6.151
© 2001–2024 by Dr. H. Weinreich, Hamburg, Germany